'We did everything we could': An account of toxic leadership

• Published in: The International journal of health planning and management 2021-11, Vol.36 (6), p.1972-1989
• Main Author: Paton, Calum
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Border stations; Borders; Boris Johnson; Competence; compliant scientific chiefs; COVID-19; Death; Death & dying; Declarations; disastrous outcomes; Government; Health administration; Health status; Immunization; incompetence and recklessness; Leadership; Libertarianism; Mortality; Mutation; National security; Pandemics; Policies; Policy making; Political culture; Quarantine; Speeches; UK Covid policy; Vaccination; Viruses
• ISSN: 0749-6753; 1099-1751
• DOI: 10.1002/hpm.3264

Background The UK government's reckless and incompetent response to Covid‐19 has produced an outcome which is amongst the worst in the world, and arguably the worst in terms of deaths per 100,000 population of major countries (especially when one measures mortality from Covid in terms of cause of death on the death certificate, rather than the UK government's own measure—death of a tested individual within 28 days of testing). This article updates my initial analysis in this journal over a year ago, and traces the negligent and shambolic policy‐making, and supine official scientific advice, which has led to such a dismal outcome. Methods It does so by examining the policies and approach of the UK government from the begining of the pandemic (in UK terms, January 2020) up to June 2021. All relevant declarations, speeches, decisions, public interviews and policies were noted on a daily basis, examined and critically assessed—along with daily data and information over the whole period on Covid's threat to, and spread across, the UK. Conclusions On three successive occasions, Boris Johnson and his compliant Ministers acted too late and too weakly to prevent avoidable death and illness. At the time of writing the vaccination programme in the UK has been destabilised by the government—yet again—having failed to secure its borders, this time against the Delta variant (Indian mutation) of the virus. Overall, in terms of border control, quarantine, testing, tracing, isolation and timely and enforced lockdown, the government put short‐term, superficial considerations above coherent strategy. It dressed up its incompetence as a superficial libertarianism and defence of the economy, but thereby managed to achieve the worst of all worlds in terms of three egregious failures—appalling health outcomes; (ironically) worse economic damage than countries which took draconian action; and (also ironically) continually recurring restrictions as a result of earlier failure to take strong action to suppress Covid and keep it at bay. Public reaction in England (unlike in Scotland and Wales) to the Johnson government's shenanigans has not been commensurate with that government's level of failure, which sadly reflects a debasement of the political culture in England.