Longitudinal Assessment to Evaluate Continued Certification and Lifelong Learning in Healthcare Professionals: A Scoping Review

• Published in: Evaluation & the Health Professions 2023-09, Vol.46 (3), p.199-212
• Main Authors: Ward, Robyn C., Baker, Kathy A., Spence, Dennis, Leonard, Colleen, Sapp, Alysha, Choudhry, Shahid A.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Certification; Competence; Evaluation; Health care industry; Learning; Lifelong learning; Medical personnel; Pilot projects; Tests
• ISSN: 0163-2787; 1552-3918
• DOI: 10.1177/01632787231164381

The balance of lifelong learning with assessment for continued certification is a challenge faced by healthcare professions. The value of single-point-in-time assessments has been questioned, and a shift to longitudinal assessments (LA) has been undertaken to assess lifelong learning over-time. This scoping review was conducted to inform healthcare certifying organizations who are considering LA as an assessment tool of competence and lifelong learning in healthcare professionals. A search of 6 databases and grey literature yielded 957 articles. After screening and removal of duplicates, 14 articles were included. Most articles were background studies informing the underpinnings of LA in the form of progress testing, pilot studies, and process of implementation. Progress testing is used in educational settings. Pilot studies reported satisfaction with LA’s ease of use, online format, and provision of lifelong learning. Implementation processes reveal that key aspects of success include stakeholder participation, phased rollout, and a publicly available content outline. Initial outcomes data affirm that LA addresses knowledge gaps, and results in improved performance on maintenance of certification exams. Future research is needed to substantiate validity evidence of LA and its correlation with high-stakes exam performance when assessing lifelong learning and continued competence of healthcare professionals over time.