Conspiracy Theory as Individual and Group Behavior: Observations from the Flat Earth International Conference

• Published in: Topics in cognitive science 2024-04, Vol.16 (2), p.187-205
• Main Authors: Fernbach, Philip M., Bogard, Jonathan E.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cognition & reasoning; Community of knowledge; Confirmation bias; Conspiracy; Conspiracy theories; Explanatory coherence; False belief; Flat Earth; Humans; Illusion of explanatory depth; International conferences; Knowledge; Mass Behavior; Social Sciences
• ISSN: 1756-8757; 1756-8765
• DOI: 10.1111/tops.12662

Conspiratorial thinking has been with humanity for a long time but has recently grown as a source of societal concern and as a subject of research in the cognitive and social sciences. We propose a three‐tiered framework for the study of conspiracy theories: (1) cognitive processes, (2) the individual, and (3) social processes and communities of knowledge. At the level of cognitive processes, we identify explanatory coherence and faulty belief updating as critical ideas. At the level of the community of knowledge, we explore how conspiracy communities facilitate false belief by promoting a contagious sense of understanding, and how community norms catalyze the biased assimilation of evidence. We review recent research on conspiracy theories and explain how conspiratorial thinking emerges from the interaction of individual and group processes. As a case study, we describe observations the first author made while attending the Flat Earth International Conference, a meeting of conspiracy theorists who believe the Earth is flat. Rather than treating conspiracy belief as pathological, we take the perspective that is an extreme outcome of common cognitive processes. We propose a three‐tiered framework for the study of conspiracy theories: (1) cognitive processes, (2) the individual, and (3) social processes and communities of knowledge. We review recent research on conspiracy theories and explain how conspiratorial thinking emerges from the interaction of individual and group processes. As a case study, we describe observations the first author made while attending the Flat Earth International Conference, a meeting of conspiracy theorists who believe the Earth is flat.