Using meta-analysis to explore the roles of global upwelling exposure and experimental design in bivalve responses to low pH

• Published in: The Science of the total environment 2023-12, Vol.902, p.165900-165900, Article 165900
• Main Authors: Czaja, Raymond, Pales-Espinosa, Emmanuelle, Cerrato, Robert M., Lwiza, Kamazima, Allam, Bassem
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bivalve; Experimental design; meta-analysis; Metabolism; Ocean acidification; Upwelling
• ISSN: 0048-9697; 1879-1026
• DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.165900

Low pH conditions, associated with ocean acidification, represent threats to many commercially and ecologically important organisms, including bivalves. However, there are knowledge gaps regarding factors explaining observed differences in biological responses to low pH in laboratory experiments. Specific sources of local adaptation such as upwelling exposure and the role of experimental design, such as carbonate chemistry parameter changes, should be considered. Linking upwelling exposure, as an individual oceanographic phenomenon, to responses measured in laboratory experiments may further our understanding of local adaptation to global change. Here, meta-analysis is used to test the hypotheses that upwelling exposure and experimental design affect outcomes of individual, laboratory-based studies that assess bivalve metabolic (clearance and respiration rate) responses to low pH. Results show that while bivalves generally decrease metabolic activity in response to low pH, upwelling exposure and experimental design can significantly impact outcomes. Bivalves from downwelling or weak upwelling areas decrease metabolic activity in response to low pH, but bivalves from strong upwelling areas increase or do not change metabolic activity in response to low pH. Furthermore, experimental temperature, exposure time and magnitude of the change in carbonate chemistry parameters all significantly affect outcomes. These results suggest that bivalves from strong upwelling areas may be less sensitive to low pH. This furthers our understanding of local adaptation to global change by demonstrating that upwelling alone can explain up to 49 % of the variability associated with bivalve metabolic responses to low pH. Furthermore, when interpreting outcomes of individual, laboratory experiments, scientists should be aware that higher temperatures, shorter exposure times and larger changes in carbonate chemistry parameters may increase the chance of suppressed metabolic activity. [Display omitted] •Meta-analysis was used to assess bivalve responses to low pH.•Strong upwelling regions may yield bivalves that are less sensitive to low pH.•Upwelling explains up to 49 % variability of bivalve metabolic responses to low pH.•Larger carbonate chemistry deltas in experiments yield stronger responses.