Pyro-Catalytic Degradation of Pyrene by Bentonite-Supported Transition Metals: Mechanistic Insights and Trade-Offs with Low Pyrolysis Temperature

• Published in: Environmental science & technology 2023-09, Vol.57 (38), p.14373-14383
• Main Authors: Denison, Sara B., Jin, Peixuan, Dias Da Silva, Priscilla, Chu, Chun, Moorthy, Bhagavatula, Senftle, Thomas P., Zygourakis, Kyriacos, Alvarez, Pedro J. J.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Aromatic compounds; Bentonite; Catalysts; Charge transfer; Chemical reactions; Copper; Cytotoxicity; Decomposition; Degradation; Detoxification; Ion exchange; Low temperature; Occurrence, Fate, and Transport of Aquatic and Terrestrial Contaminants; Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons; Pyrene; Pyrolysis; Soil contamination; Soil pollution; Soil remediation; Soil temperature; Temperature; Toxicity; Transition metals; Zinc
• ISSN: 0013-936X; 1520-5851
• DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.3c04487

Transition metal catalysts can significantly enhance the pyrolytic remediation of soils contaminated with polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Significantly higher pyrene removal efficiency was observed after the pyrolytic treatment of Fe-enriched bentonite (1.8% wt ion-exchanged content) relative to natural bentonite or soil (i.e., 93% vs 48% and 4%) at the unprecedentedly low temperature of 150 °C with only 15 min treatment time. DFT calculations showed that bentonite surfaces with Fe3+ or Cu2+ adsorb pyrene stronger than surfaces with Zn2+ or Na+. Enhanced pyrene adsorption results from increased charge transfer from its aromatic π-bonds to the cation site, which destabilizes pyrene allowing for faster degradation at lower temperatures. UV–Vis and GC–MS analyses revealed pyrene decomposition products in extracts of samples treated at 150 °C, including small aromatic compounds. As the pyrolysis temperature increased above 200 °C, product distribution shifted from extractable compounds to char coating the residue particles. No extractable byproducts were detected after treatment at 400 °C, indicating that char was the final product of pyrene decomposition. Tests with human lung cells showed that extracts of samples pyrolyzed at 150 °C were toxic; thus, high removal efficiency by pyrolytic treatment does not guarantee detoxification. No cytotoxicity was observed for extracts from Fe-bentonite samples treated at 300 °C, inferring that char is an appropriate treatment end point. Overall, we demonstrate that transition metals in clay can catalyze pyrolytic reactions at relatively low temperatures to decrease the energy and contact times required to meet cleanup standards. However, mitigating residual toxicity may require higher pyrolysis temperatures.