A diatom-based approach to refine nutrient concentrations compatible with the “good” status of Northern Italy rivers

• Published in: The Science of the total environment 2024-02, Vol.912, p.169444-169444, Article 169444
• Main Authors: Bona, Francesca, Falasco, Elisa, Nizzoli, Daniele, Zoppi, Marta, La Morgia, Valentina
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Diatoms; Nutrient thresholds; River ecological classification; Rivers; Water Framework Directive
• ISSN: 0048-9697; 1879-1026
• DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.169444

The identification of ecologically sound thresholds represents an important step toward improving the ecological status of rivers through appropriate measures to contain nutrient loads. The aim of the present study was to estimate phosphorus and nitrogen concentrations compatible with the achievement of the “good” ecological status of rivers from data collected in the Po River District, the largest hydrographic system in Italy. For this purpose, relationships between the diatom index used in Italy for the national assessment of the stream ecological status, the ICMi (Intercalibration Common Metric index), and total phosphorus and nitrate concentrations were analyzed using monitoring data collected between 2009 and 2019. The Po River Basin encompasses five distinct river types, from Alpine to Mediterranean to Lowlands, characterized by different anthropogenic pressures and water quality. Through regression analysis between the ICMi and nutrient concentrations, we estimated ranges of the latter values corresponding to a “good” ecological status for each river type. The resulting thresholds are far more stringent than the limits set by the Italian legislation for water quality classification. This is particularly true for total phosphorus, whose threshold value should be roughly halved for all river types. For nitrates, the results are more differentiated according to river type: the estimated thresholds are much more stringent than those currently in use for siliceous Alpine and Mediterranean rivers. Moreover, the availability of such a large database allowed also to assess the influence of one nutrient over the other on the diatom community and to highlight some critical issues in the formulation of ICMi for Mediterranean rivers. [Display omitted] •Developed regression models to set up ecological-sound nutrient thresholds•Different river types have distinct thresholds estimated with diatom indices.•P thresholds should be halved in comparison to current Italian legislation.•Nutrient concentrations are critically high in lowland and in intermittent rivers.