Time-dependent hormesis transfer from five high-frequency personal care product components to mixtures

• Published in: Environmental research 2024-05, Vol.248, p.118418-118418, Article 118418
• Main Authors: Cheng, Rujun, Huang, Peng, Ding, Ting-Ting, Gu, Zhong-Wei, Tao, Meng-Ting, Liu, Shu-Shen
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Actual mixture ratio; Characteristic parameters; Cosmetics; Edetic Acid; High-frequency components; Hormesis; Hormesis transmission; Time-dependent; Vibrio
• ISSN: 0013-9351; 1096-0953
• DOI: 10.1016/j.envres.2024.118418

There is potential for personal care products (PCPs) components and mixtures to induce hormesis. How hormesis is related to time and transmitted from components to mixtures are not clear. In this paper, we conducted determination of components in 16 PCP products and then ran frequent itemset mining on the component data. Five high-frequency components (HFCs), betaine (BET), 1,3-butanediol (BUT), ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid disodium salt (EDTA), glycerol (GLO), and phenoxyethanol (POE), and 14 mixtures were identified. For each mixture system, one mixture ray with the actual mixture ratios in the products was selected. Time-dependent microplate toxicity analysis was used to test the luminescence inhibition toxicity of five HFCs and 14 mixture rays to Vibrio qinghaiensis sp.-Q67 at 12 concentration gradients and eight exposure times. It is showed that BET, EDTA, POE, and 13 mixture rays containing at least one J-type component showed time-dependent hormesis. Characteristic parameters used to describe hormesis revealed that the absolute value of the maximum stimulatory effect (|Emin|) generally increased with time. Notably, mixtures composed of POE and S-type components showed greater |Emin| than POE alone at the same time. Importantly, the maximum stimulatory effective concentration, NOEC/the zero effective concentration point, and EC50 remained relatively stable. Nine hormesis transmission phenomena were observed in different mixture rays. While all mixtures primarily exhibited additive action, varying degrees of synergism and antagonism were noted in binary mixtures, with no strong synergism or antagonism observed in ternary and quaternary mixtures. These findings offer valuable insights for the screening of HFCs and their mixtures, as well as the study of hormesis transmission in personal care products. [Display omitted] •Five high-frequency components and their 14 mixtures were identified by FIM.•All ECmin, NOEC/ZEP, and EC50 did not significantly change over time.•The maximum stimulation of J-type components and mixture rays increased over time.•There was no strong antagonism or synergism in ternary and quaternary mixtures.•Mixtures composed of POE and S-type components showed greater |Emin| than POE alone.