Resident perspectives on the role of gender in operative experience during general surgery residency training: A mixed-methods study

• Published in: The American journal of surgery 2024-11, Vol.237, p.115755, Article 115755
• Main Authors: Winer, Leah K., Panzica, Nicole, Lynch, Kenneth, Parker, Catherine, Lancaster, Rachael, Gillis, Andrea, Lindeman, Brenessa, Chen, Herbert, Fazendin, Jessica, Cortez, Alexander R., Zmijewski, Polina
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bias; Consortia; Demographics; Discrimination; Ethnicity; Females; Gender; Gender disparities; General surgery residency; Human bias; Nurses; Operative experience; Perceptions; Polls & surveys; Qualitative research; Surgery; Training
• ISSN: 0002-9610; 1879-1883; 1879-1883
• DOI: 10.1016/j.amjsurg.2024.04.026

It remains unclear why female general surgery residents perform fewer cases than male peers. This exploratory study investigated possible contributors to gender-based disparities and solutions for improving equity in operative experience. Surveys, including Likert scale and free-text questions, were distributed to 21 accredited general surgery residency programs. There were 96 respondents, of whom 69% were female. 22% of females personally experienced barriers to operative experience versus 13% of males (p ​= ​0.41), while 52% of female residents believed operative training was affected by gender (p ​= ​0.004). Inductive analysis revealed the most common barrier to operating room participation was floor work/clinical tasks. The most common barrier for female residents was perceived sexism/gender bias, with subthemes of “misidentification,” “feeling unwelcome,” and “poor trust/autonomy.” To improve parity, residents proposed structured program-level review, feedback, and transparent expectations about case assignments. Female general surgery residents believe gender bias impacts training. Further mixed-methods research is crucial to determine the cause of gender-based disparities in operative experience. [Display omitted] •Prior studies reveal gender and sex-based differences in general surgery case logs and operative experience.•In this multicenter study, 53% of female general surgery residents felt that gender influences training quality.•Sexism and gender bias were the predominant perceived barriers to operating room participation for female residents.