Variation in induced responses in volatile and non-volatile metabolites among six willow species: Do willow species share responses to herbivory?

• Published in: Phytochemistry (Oxford) 2024-10, Vol.226, p.114222, Article 114222
• Main Authors: Mezzomo, Priscila, Leong, Jing V., Vodrážka, Petr, Moos, Martin, Jorge, Leonardo R., Volfová, Tereza, Michálek, Jan, de L. Ferreira, Paola, Kozel, Petr, Sedio, Brian E., Volf, Martin
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Chemical variation; Induced defences; Salix; Secondary metabolites; VOCs
• ISSN: 0031-9422; 1873-3700; 1873-3700
• DOI: 10.1016/j.phytochem.2024.114222

Chemical variation is a critical aspect affecting performance among co-occurring plants. High chemical variation in metabolites with direct effects on insect herbivores supports chemical niche partitioning, and it can reduce the number of herbivores shared by co-occurring plant species. In contrast, low intraspecific variation in metabolites with indirect effects, such as induced volatile organic compounds (VOCs), may improve the attraction of specialist predators or parasitoids as they show high specificity to insect herbivores. We explored whether induced chemical variation following herbivory by various insect herbivores differs between VOCs vs. secondary non-volatile metabolites (non-VOCs) and salicinoids with direct effects on herbivores in six closely related willow species. Willow species identity explained most variation in VOCs (18.4%), secondary non-VOCs (41.1%) and salicinoids (60.7%). The variation explained by the independent effect of the herbivore treatment was higher in VOCs (2.8%) compared to secondary non-VOCs (0.5%) and salicinoids (0.5%). At the level of individual VOCs, willow species formed groups, as some responded similarly to the same herbivores. Most non-VOCs and salicinoids were upregulated by sap-suckers compared to other herbivore treatments and control across the willow species. In contrast, induced responses in non-VOCs and salicinoids to other herbivores largely differed between the willows. Our results suggest that induced responses broadly differ between various types of chemical defences, with VOCs and non-VOCs showing different levels of specificity and similarity across plant species. This may further contribute to flexible plant responses to herbivory and affect how closely related plants share or partition their chemical niches. [Display omitted] •Willow species formed groups of VOC response to insect herbivory.•Non-volatile metabolites and salicinoids showed species-specific responses.•Salicinoids exhibited largely uniform responses to damage by the sapsucker Aphrophora salicina across multiple willow species.•Divergent responses in volatile and non-volatile metabolites contribute to flexible responses against herbivory.