Towards an ecosystem capacity to stabilise organic carbon in soils

• Published in: Global change biology 2024-08, Vol.30 (8), p.e17453-n/a
• Main Authors: Poeplau, Christopher, Dechow, Rene, Begill, Neha, Don, Axel
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Carbon; Carbon - analysis; Carbon dioxide; Carbon Sequestration; Clay; Clay minerals; Clay soils; Ecosystem; Estimates; Limiting factors; mineral associated organic carbon; mineralogical capacity; Mineralogy; Models, Theoretical; net primary production; Net Primary Productivity; Organic carbon; Organic soils; Primary production; RothC; Silt; Soil; Soil - chemistry; Soil investigations; soil organic carbon; Soil properties; Soil texture; Soils; SOM fractionation; Temperate zones; Texture
• ISSN: 1354-1013; 1365-2486; 1365-2486
• DOI: 10.1111/gcb.17453

Soil organic carbon (SOC) accrual, and particularly the formation of fine fraction carbon (OCfine), has a large potential to act as sink for atmospheric CO2. For reliable estimates of this potential and efficient policy advice, the major limiting factors for OCfine accrual need to be understood. The upper boundary of the correlation between fine mineral particles (silt + clay) and OCfine is widely used to estimate the maximum mineralogical capacity of soils to store OCfine, suggesting that mineral surfaces get C saturated. Using a dataset covering the temperate zone and partly other climates on OCfine contents and a SOC turnover model, we provide two independent lines of evidence, that this empirical upper boundary does not indicate C saturation. Firstly, the C loading of the silt + clay fraction was found to strongly exceed previous saturation estimates in coarse‐textured soils, which raises the question of why this is not observed in fine‐textured soils. Secondly, a subsequent modelling exercise revealed, that for 74% of all investigated soils, local net primary production (NPP) would not be sufficient to reach a C loading of 80 g C kg−1 silt + clay, which was previously assumed to be a general C saturation point. The proportion of soils with potentially enough NPP to reach that point decreased strongly with increasing silt + clay content. High C loadings can thus hardly be reached in more fine‐textured soils, even if all NPP would be available as C input. As a pragmatic approach, we introduced texture‐dependent, empirical maximum C loadings of the fine fraction, that decreased from 160 g kg−1 in coarse to 75 g kg−1 in most fine‐textured soils. We conclude that OCfine accrual in soils is mainly limited by C inputs and is strongly modulated by texture, mineralogy, climate and other site properties, which could be formulated as an ecosystem capacity to stabilise SOC. This article provides evidence, that the stabilisation of carbon in soils is primarily limited by carbon inputs. Using a large, temperate‐zone centred dataset, and a well‐established carbon model, we show that the empirical upper limit of carbon associated with silt and clay particles does not resemble a maximum mineralogical capacity. Without the given natural limitations of net primary production and C input limitation, soils could most likely stabilise and store much more soil carbon than commonly observed.