Instant messengers and health professionals’ agency in Russian clinical settings

• Published in: Social science & medicine (1982) 2024-10, Vol.359, p.117281, Article 117281
• Main Author: Borozdina, Ekaterina
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Digital health technologies; Female; Health Personnel - psychology; Healthcare professionals; Humans; Information Dissemination - methods; Instant messengers; Interviews as Topic; Male; Professional agency; Professionalism; Qualitative Research; Russia
• ISSN: 0277-9536; 1873-5347; 1873-5347
• DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117281

This research examines how Russian healthcare professionals use instant messengers (in particular, the group chat function on instant messengers) for work-related tasks. Based on qualitative interviews with Russian doctors and nurses conducted in spring 2020, the article explores how the informal implementation of instant messenger's group chat function facilitated and shaped health professionals' agency in two key areas of professional control: work regulation and medical knowledge. In the first case, front-line healthcare professionals used instant messengers to make horizontal connections, share relevant regulatory information, and smooth over organizational discrepancies. Hospital management, on the other hand, employed this technology as an additional tool for imposing top-down control on employees. The adoption of instant messengers for medical knowledge dissemination is more consistently linked with professional logic. By utilizing this technology, healthcare personnel not only shared clinical recommendations, publications, and clinical experience, but also fostered solidarity within the country's medical community and forged connections with international medical professionals. These findings support the social science assumption concerning the contextualized character of both professionalism and digital innovations in healthcare. In state-dominated Russian healthcare, instant messengers not only assist structurally disempowered professionals in dealing with pragmatic challenges, but also create more space for their ground-level discretion in the face of intense administrative pressure. Moreover, since the messaging technology helps Russian health workers in navigating and agentially connecting different knowledge and regulatory landscapes, it also fosters a new - trans-local and more reflexive – form of professionalism in post-socialist medicine. •Health workers informally adopted instant messengers.•Messengers helped in handling pandemic challenges.•Messengers facilitated and shaped professionals' agency.•The use of messengers fostered connective professionalism.