Human Rights, Democracy, and the Inescapability of Politics; or, Human Dignity Thick and Thin

• Published in: Israel law review 2005, Vol.38 (1-2), p.358-377
• Main Author: Mirsky, Yehudah
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Arab-Israeli conflict; D. The ICJ's Advisory Opinion and International Relations Theory; Democracy; Dualism; Human rights; International Court of Justice; Israel; Palestinian Authority; Terrorism
• ISSN: 0021-2237; 2047-9336
• DOI: 10.1017/S0021223700012760

The essay places the ICJ opinion in a broader legal and political context and argues that the failure to distinguish between democratic and non-democratic regimes characterizing the ICJ advisory opinion reflects broader trends with potentially ruinous consequences for the enterprise of human rights promotion itself. The ICJ opinion's willful ignoring of Israel's democratic character yielded a tendentious and inconsistent ruling. By contrast the Israel High Court of Justice's decision invalidating portions of Israel's security wall reflects a healthy understanding of a democracy's needs and limitations, as reflected in that court's proportionality standard of review. The ICJ willingly blurred crucial distinctions between democratic regimes that genuinely adhere, however imperfectly, to principles of human rights in their own governance, and those states and actors that do not, a distinction made all the more imperative by the events of September 11. The judicialization of human rights in the post-Cold War era takes place against the background of a tensile relationship between human rights advocacy and democracy promotion during the Cold War. While human rights represent an essentially legal idea, democracy a political idea. In closing, the essay lays out one basic, hopefully workable, conceptual division of labor between human rights and democracy as complementary elements of a broader project of human dignity, in which human rights represents a “thin” universal conception of human dignity, while democracy offers a process whereby that conception can be “thickened” in various political, social and cultural contexts around the globe.