Monte Carlo Simulations of the Solution Structure of Simple Alcohols in Water−Acetonitrile Mixtures

• Published in: The journal of physical chemistry. B 2005-03, Vol.109 (12), p.5855-5872
• Main Authors: Nagy, Peter I, Erhardt, Paul W
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Acetonitriles - chemistry; Alcohols - chemistry; Computer Simulation; Electrochemistry; Hydrogen Bonding; Molecular Structure; Monte Carlo Method; Solutions - chemistry; Solvents - chemistry; Water - chemistry
• ISSN: 1520-6106; 1520-5207
• DOI: 10.1021/jp045570q

Monte Carlo simulations have been performed to explore the solution structure of ethyl, isopropyl, isobutyl, and tertiary butyl alcohols in pure water, pure acetonitrile, and different mixtures of the two solvents. The explicit solvent studies in NpT ensembles at T = 298 K illustrate that the solute “discriminates” the solvent's components and that the composition of the first solvation shell differs from that of the bulk solution. Since the polarizable continuum dielectric method (PCM) does not presently model the solvation of molecules with both polar and apolar sites in mixed protic solvents, we suggest a direction for further program development wherein a continuum dielectric method would accept more than one solvent and the solute sites would be solvated by user-defined solvent components. The prevailing solvation model will be determined upon the lowest free energy calculated for a particular solvation pattern of the solute having a specific conformational/tautomeric state. Characterization of equilibrium hydrogen-bond formation becomes a complicated problem that depends on the chemical properties of the solute and its conformation, as well as upon the varying nature of the first solvation shell. For example, while the number of hydrogen bonds to secondary and tertiary alcohol solutes are nearly constant in pure water and in water−acetonitrile mixtures with at least 50% water content, the number of hydrogen bonds to primary alcohols gradually decreases for most of their conformations when acetonitrile content is increased. Nonetheless, the calculations indicate that O−H···Owater hydrogen bonds are still possible in a small fraction of the arrangements for the solution models with water content of 30% or less. The isopentene solute does not form any observable hydrogen bonds, despite having an electron-rich, double-bond site.