The competition between PAOs (phosphorus accumulating organisms) and GAOs (glycogen accumulating organisms) in EBPR (enhanced biological phosphorus removal) systems at different temperatures and the effects on system performance

• Published in: Water science and technology 2003-01, Vol.47 (11), p.1-8
• Main Authors: ERDAL, U. G, ERDAL, Z. K, RANDAL, C. W
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accumulation; Acetates; Acetates - metabolism; Acetic acid; Applied sciences; Bioaccumulation; Biological and medical sciences; Biological competition; Biological effects; Biological treatment of waters; Bioreactors; Biotechnology; Chemical reactions; Competition; Competitors; Electron microscopy; Environment and pollution; Exact sciences and technology; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; General purification processes; Glycogen; Glycogen - metabolism; Glycogen - pharmacokinetics; Industrial applications and implications. Economical aspects; Kinetics; Metabolism; Models, Theoretical; Organisms; Phosphorus; Phosphorus - isolation & purification; Phosphorus - metabolism; Phosphorus - pharmacokinetics; Phosphorus removal; Plants (botany); Pollution; Proliferation; Removal; Sludge; Temperature; Temperature effects; Transmission electron microscopy; Waste Disposal, Fluid; Wastewater; Wastewaters; Water Purification - methods; Water treatment and pollution; Yeast; Yeasts
• ISSN: 0273-1223; 1996-9732
• DOI: 10.2166/wst.2003.0579

It is well known and firmly established that the rate of chemical and biochemical reactions slow down as temperature decreases. Nevertheless, several studies have reported that the efficiency of enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR) improves as temperature decreases. However, several recent studies have reported that EBPR reaction rates decrease with temperature decrease in accordance with the Arrhenius relationship. This study was designed to more thoroughly investigate this controversy using two UCT plants fed with a synthetic wastewater consisting primarily of acetate as the COD form, and a small amount of supplemental yeast extract. Experiments were performed over temperatures ranging from 5 to 20 degrees C. The results showed that, even though the kinetic rates decrease as temperature decreases, EBPR systems perform better at colder temperatures. The reason for better system performance is apparently related to reduced competition for substrate in the non-oxic zones, which results in an increased population of PAOs and, thus, greater EBPR efficiency. The proliferation of PAOs apparently occurs because they are psychrophilic whereas their competitors are not. The experiments showed that the EBPR sludges accumulated high concentrations of both PHA and glycogen at 20 degrees C, but accumulated more PHA and much less glycogen at 5 degrees C. Although the results could be interpreted as the result of changes in the PAO-GAO competition, Mann-Whitney non-parametric comparisons of transmission electron microscopy examinations revealed no indication of the presence of GAOs population under any temperature conditions. Regardless, mass balances of the glycogen data showed that the involvement of glycogen is less at cold temperature, even though EBPR was greater. Unlike current EBPR models (e.g. Mino model), the results suggest that glycogen metabolism is not a precursor for EBPR biochemistry. The results also indicate that temperature not only may cause selective pressure on the dominant organisms, but also may force them to use a different metabolic pathway as temperature decreases.