Influence of isolation on the recovery of pond mesocosms from the application of an insecticide. II. Benthic macroinvertebrate responses

• Published in: Environmental toxicology and chemistry 2007-06, Vol.26 (6), p.1280-1290
• Main Authors: Caquet, Thierry, Hanson, Mark L., Roucaute, Marc, Graham, David W., Lagadic, Laurent
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Analysis of Variance; Animals; Aquatic higher tier assessment; Chironominae; Community composition; Connectivity; Deltamethrin; Fresh Water; Insecticides; Insecticides - toxicity; Insects; Invertebrates - classification; Invertebrates - drug effects; Larvae; Litter; Macroinvertebrates; Nitriles - toxicity; Pesticides; Plankton; Polyvinyl chloride; Ponds; Pyrethrins - toxicity; Recolonization; Recovery dynamics; Risk assessment; Water Pollutants, Chemical - toxicity
• ISSN: 0730-7268; 1552-8618
• DOI: 10.1897/06-250R.1

The immediate response and recovery of the macrobenthic communities of nonisolated and isolated freshwater outdoor 9 m3 mesocosms following an acute stress caused by the addition of deltamethrin were studied over a 14‐month period. To discriminate between internal and external recovery mechanisms, half of the treated ponds were covered by 1‐mm mesh lids that restricted aerial recolonization. Both structural (abundance of the different taxonomic groups) and functional (litter breakdown) parameters were monitored. Insects were broadly reduced in numbers by deltamethrin addition. In general, noninsect groups were not affected or increased in abundance in deltamethrin‐treated ponds, probably because of relative insensitivity to deltamethrin, reduced predation, and lower competition for food. No major change in litter breakdown rates were seen, probably because of functional redundancy among the macrobenthic community. Chironominae larvae recovered in open, treated mesocosms 62 d after deltamethrin addition and most insect groups recovered 84 d after the treatment date. However, the presence of lids significantly reduced insect recovery rate, suggesting that it largely depends on the immigration of winged forms (i.e., external recovery) from surrounding non‐ or less affected systems. These results indicate that the recovery time of macrobenthic communities in an affected natural pond would depend on spatial characteristics of the landscape and also the season that exposure occurs. Isolated ecosystems would display posttreatment insect recovery dynamics very different from highly connected ones, evolving toward alternate pseudoequilibrium states, possibly with lower biodiversity but with preserved functionality. Consequences for higher tier risk assessment of pesticides are discussed.