Taking the Hit: Focusing on Caregiver “Error” Masks Organizational-Level Risk Factors for Nursing Aide Assault

• Published in: Qualitative health research 2008-03, Vol.18 (3), p.334-346
• Main Authors: Morgan, Debra G., Crossley, Margaret F., Stewart, Norma J., D'Arcy, Carl, Forbes, Dorothy A., Normand, Sandy A., Cammer, Allison L.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Aggression; Assault; Assaults; Caregivers - legislation & jurisprudence; Data Collection; Focus Groups; Health technology assessment; Humans; Interviews as Topic; Long term care; Long-Term Care - legislation & jurisprudence; Long-Term Care - organization & administration; Mandatory Reporting; Nurses' Aides - ethics; Nurses' Aides - legislation & jurisprudence; Nursing; Nursing homes; Nursing Homes - organization & administration; Occupational Health; Prospective Studies; Qualitative research; Risk Factors; Rural communities; Rural Population; Violence - ethics; Violence - legislation & jurisprudence; Violence - prevention & control; Work environment
• ISSN: 1049-7323; 1552-7557
• DOI: 10.1177/1049732307313754

Beliefs about the causes of events have implications for emotional reactions, distress, expectations for the future, and behavioral responses. In this article we report on two issues: the organizational context that contributes to nursing aide (NA) assault and reporting, and serendipitous findings that arose from investigating unexpected response rates to a survey. Data were collected in 11 rural nursing homes using a structured prospective event-reporting diary to collect detailed information about incidents of physical aggression, followed by focus groups to further explore NAs' perceptions of these events. Here we report on analysis of 19 focus groups conducted with 138 NAs. Participants described organizational-level factors that constrained their practice, affected their interactions with residents, and created a context that put them at risk for physical assault. These factors also affected their willingness to provide written documentation about aggressive incidents. The key issues were frustration at being blamed for causing aggression, lack of action to address the problem, and a desire for respect and involvement in decision making. Organizational changes are needed to modify the contextual factors contributing to assault risk. Researchers must be willing to modify study designs to more fully understand the nature of the problem studied.