Foreclosing on the American dream? The financial consequences of low-income homeownership

• Published in: Housing policy debate 2010-09, Vol.20 (4), p.707-742
• Main Authors: Santiago, Anna Maria, Galster, George C., Santiago-San Roman, Ana H., Tucker, Cristina M., Kaiser, Angela A., Grace, Rebecca A.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Americans; assets; Black; defaults; Economic policy; Equity; Ethnicity; Home ownership; homeownership; Households; Housing; Housing policy; indicators; Latino; Longitudinal studies; Low income; Low income groups; Neighborhoods; Personal finance; Real estate; Real estate market; Studies; Sustainability; U.S.A; Wealth
• ISSN: 1051-1482; 2152-050X
• DOI: 10.1080/10511482.2010.506194

Federal programs have consistently encouraged ever-lower-income households to buy homes, despite concerns about the long-term sustainability and desirability of homeownership from the perspective of wealth-building, especially since the recent housing market collapse and the epidemic of mortgage foreclosures. We ask in this paper: can very low-income households build wealth through sustainable homeownership, with the aid of an innovative public program? We answer this question by examining 122 very low-income households who purchased their homes between 1996 and 2007 after completing an extensive asset-building and homeownership education/counseling program offered by the Housing Authority of the City and County of Denver (DHA), called HOP. We analyze our own longitudinal surveys and focus groups, as well as data compiled from administrative agency sources, real estate records, and longitudinal census data from the Neighborhood Change Database and the Piton Foundation's Neighborhood Facts Database. We find that homeownership attained through HOP typically did provide very low-income households with opportunities to build home equity (both absolutely and relative to generic homeowner cohorts in Denver) and net wealth, although this was contingent on time of purchase and ethnicity. Our multivariate analyses revealed that changes in annualized home equity appreciation were associated with the ethnic composition of the neighborhood and age of property. Annualized wealth accumulation was associated with annualized home equity appreciation, being married throughout the tenure of homeownership, and year of home purchase. HOP homebuyers received exceptionally favorable initial mortgage terms and conditions, often enhanced with down-payment assistance from their own DHA escrow account or from local housing and neighborhood development organizations, resulting in a dramatically low rate of default and foreclosure to date. Moreover, HOP homebuyers were not immune to financial stresses, and the continuing lack of wealth for many makes them vulnerable to future interruptions in primary wage earner's employment or health. We discuss the implications for low-income homeownership policy and argue that the goal of expanding homeownership opportunities should not be abandoned.