An alternative generic groundwater-to-indoor air attenuation factor for application in commercial, industrial, and other nonresidential settings

• Published in: Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association (1995) 2023-04, Vol.73 (4), p.258-270
• Main Authors: Levy, Laurent C., Hallberg, Keri E., Gonzalez-Abraham, Rodrigo, Lutes, Christopher C., Lund, Loren G., Caldwell, Donna, Walker, Teresie R.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Air Pollution, Indoor - analysis; Attenuation; Buildings; Chlorination; Commercial buildings; Empirical analysis; Environmental protection; Federal agencies; Gases - analysis; Groundwater; Groundwater data; Hydrologic data; Indoor air quality; Indoor environments; Industrial buildings; Intrusion; Nonresidential buildings; Organic compounds; Residential areas; Residential buildings; Screening; State regulations; United States; Vapors; VOCs; Volatile organic compounds; Volatile Organic Compounds - analysis
• ISSN: 1096-2247; 2162-2906
• DOI: 10.1080/10962247.2023.2175740

The default groundwater-to-indoor air attenuation factor (AF) of 10 −3 (0.001) to assess the vapor intrusion (VI) pathway and generate VI screening levels for groundwater was developed by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) based on chlorinated volatile organic compound (VOC) indoor air and groundwater data collected in residential buildings and compiled in EPA's 2012 VI database. In their VI guidance published in 2015, EPA recognized that this default AF may be overly conservative for nonresidential buildings. In 2015, the Department of Defense (DoD) began developing a first-of-its-kind VI database to assess AFs at commercial and industrial buildings at DoD installations and support the development of alternative generic AF values. This database was expanded in 2019 to include 76 buildings at 22 DoD installations across the United States and is comparable in size to the EPA VI database. The DoD database includes chlorinated VOC data from groundwater and indoor air samples collected from multiple sampling zones within these buildings. Empirical groundwater-to-indoor air AFs were calculated using similar screening methods employed by EPA, including a source strength screen, to filter out potential background source contributions unrelated to VI. Analysis of indoor air-groundwater data pairs found that there is more attenuation occurring from groundwater to indoor air in DoD commercial and industrial buildings relative to residential buildings and that the DoD buildings' AFs are one to four orders of magnitude lower than EPA's residential-based default of 10 −3 . The results support the use of a generic groundwater AF of 10 −4 (0.0001) to support VI assessment and develop groundwater screening levels specific to large commercial and industrial buildings as an alternative to the residential default AF. Implications: The use of groundwater-to-indoor air attenuation factors (AFs) is a key component of vapor intrusion (VI) pathway assessments and VI screening-level development for groundwater. Currently, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and many state regulatory agencies use a default groundwater AF of 10 −3 (0.001) based on chlorinated volatile organic compound (VOC) data collected in residential buildings. VI assessment data collected at Department of Defense (DoD) installations indicate that there is significantly more groundwater-to-indoor air attenuation occurring at DoD commercial and industrial buildings. For tha