Quantifying inherent predictability and spatial synchrony in the aphid vector Myzus persicae: field‐scale patterns of abundance and regional forecasting error in the UK

• Published in: Pest management science 2023-04, Vol.79 (4), p.1331-1341
• Main Authors: Bell, James R., Clark, Suzanne J., Stevens, Mark, Mead, Andrew
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animals; Aphids - genetics; Beta vulgaris; Entropy; Entropy of solution; Forecasting; Myzus persicae; Neonicotinoids; Permutations; Pest control; Pests; Population Dynamics; Populations; Seasons; Seed treatments; spatial synchrony; Stochasticity; Suction; Sugar; sugar beet; Sugar beets; Time series; United Kingdom; virus reservoirs; weighted permutation entropy; yellow water traps; Yellows
• ISSN: 1526-498X; 1526-4998
• DOI: 10.1002/ps.7292

Background Sugar beet is threatened by virus yellows, a disease complex vectored by aphids that reduces sugar content. We present an analysis of Myzus persicae population dynamics with and without neonicotinoid seed treatment. We use 6 years' yellow water trap and field‐collected aphid data and two decades of 12.2 m suction‐trap aphid migration data. We investigate both spatial synchrony and forecasting error to understand the structure and spatial scale of field counts and why forecasting aphid migrants lacks accuracy. Our aim is to derive statistical parameters to inform regionwide pest management strategies. Results Spatial synchrony, indicating the coincident change in counts across the region over time, is rarely present and is best described as stochastic. Uniquely, early season field populations in 2019 did show spatial synchrony to 90 km compared to the overall average weekly correlation length of 23 km. However, 70% of the time series were spatially heterogenous, indicating patchy between‐field dynamics. Field counts lacked the same seasonal trend and did not peak in the same week. Forecasts tended to under‐predict mid‐season log10 counts. A strongly negative correlation between forecasting error and the proportion of zeros was shown. Conclusion Field populations are unpredictable and stochastic, regardless of neonicotinoid seed treatment. This outcome presents a problem for decision‐support that cannot usefully provide a single regionwide solution. Weighted permutation entropy inferred that M. persicae 12.2 m suction‐trap time series had moderate to low intrinsic predictability. Early warning using a migration model tended to predict counts at lower levels than observed. © 2022 The Authors. Pest Management Science published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Society of Chemical Industry. Migrating populations of the aphid vector, Myzus persciae, have moderate to low intrinsic predictability. Field populations are stochastic, regardless of neonicotinoid seed treatment presenting a problem for decision‐support.