Detecting non-content-based response styles in survey data: An application of mixture factor analysis

• Published in: Behavior research methods 2024-04, Vol.56 (4), p.3242-3258
• Main Authors: Arias, Víctor B., Ponce, Fernando P., Garrido, Luis E., Nieto-Cañaveras, María Dolores, Martínez-Molina, Agustín, Arias, Benito
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Behavioral Science and Psychology; Cognitive Psychology; Data Interpretation, Statistical; Factor analysis; Factor Analysis, Statistical; Humans; Models, Statistical; Original Manuscript; Psychology; Self Report; Surveys; Surveys and Questionnaires
• ISSN: 1554-3528; 1554-351X; 1554-3528
• DOI: 10.3758/s13428-023-02308-w

It is common for some participants in self-report surveys to be careless, inattentive, or lacking in effort. Data quality can be severely compromised by responses that are not based on item content (non-content-based [nCB] responses), leading to strong biases in the results of data analysis and misinterpretation of individual scores. In this study, we propose a specification of factor mixture analysis (FMA) to detect nCB responses. We investigated the usefulness and effectiveness of the FMA model in detecting nCB responses using both simulated data (Study 1) and real data (Study 2). In the first study, FMA showed reasonably robust sensitivity (.60 to .86) and excellent specificity (.96 to .99) on mixed-worded scales, suggesting that FMA had superior properties as a screening tool under different sample conditions. However, FMA performance was poor on scales composed of only positive items because of the difficulty in distinguishing acquiescent patterns from valid responses representing high levels of the trait. In Study 2 (real data), FMA detected a minority of cases (6.5%) with highly anomalous response patterns. Removing these cases resulted in a large increase in the fit of the unidimensional model and a substantial reduction in spurious multidimensionality.