Healing patient, harming planet? A drive towards sustainable surgery: review of waste production and recyclability of surgical instrument packaging

• Published in: Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England 2024-07, Vol.106 (6), p.492-497
• Main Authors: Lee, Y K, Hariri, A, Ghedia, R, Tikka, T, Kim, D
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Carbon footprint; Climate change; Emissions; Hospitals; Manufacturers; Medical wastes; Packaging; Plastics; Recycling; Skin; Supply chains; Surgeons; Surgical apparatus & instruments; Sustainability; Thyroidectomy
• ISSN: 0035-8843; 1478-7083; 1478-7083
• DOI: 10.1308/rcsann.2023.0045

Healthcare contributes more than 1% of all domestic waste in the United Kingdom (UK), with operating theatre waste alone accounting for approximately 50% of all hospital waste. In November 2022, the UK Surgical Royal Colleges issued an Intercollegiate Climate Emergency Declaration and called for urgent action. We review waste production and the recyclability of surgical instrument packaging used in a common ear, nose and throat procedure (thyroidectomy) and suggest strategies to make this surgery more sustainable,. These strategies can be generalised to other surgeries. We prospectively audited packaging waste from 20 thyroidectomies performed at the Royal Marsden Hospital in the UK between July and December 2022. All packaging was weighed, categorised and analysed after the operation. On average, each thyroidectomy produced packaging waste comprising 183g (34%) of plain paper/cardboard, 167g (31%) of soft plastic film, 142g (26%) of laminated paper, 37g (7%) of hard plastic and 11g (2%) of metal foil. Of all the packaging collected, only one item had a recycling label. When extrapolated to the 7,851 thyroidectomies performed in the National Health Service during the fiscal year 2021/2022, the estimated total weight of packaging waste would be 4.2 tonnes, of which only 31.4kg would be indicated as recyclable. When converted to an estimated carbon footprint, total carbon emissions would be 1,048kg CO e, equivalent to three round trips from London to Edinburgh in a petrol car. This audit demonstrates the different categories and vast amount of packaging waste from a common operation. Manufacturers should place clear recyclability labels on packaging, and switch to recyclable materials and a digital information booklet where possible. Local waste audit and analysis can be simple first steps towards making surgery more sustainable.