Inconsistent definitions of prolonged labor in international literature: a scoping review

• Published in: AJOG global reports 2024-08, Vol.4 (3), p.100360, Article 100360
• Main Authors: Bakker, Wouter, Sandberg, Evelien M., Keetels, Sharon, Schoones, Jan W., Kujabi, Monica Lauridsen, Maaløe, Nanna, Maswime, Salome, van den Akker, Thomas
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: active support of labor; definition; Expert Reviews; labor dystocia; labor management; labor progress; partograph; prolonged first stage of labor; prolonged second stage of labor
• ISSN: 2666-5778; 2666-5778
• DOI: 10.1016/j.xagr.2024.100360

Prolonged labor is the commonest indication for intrapartum cesarean section, but definitions are inconsistent and some common definitions were recently found to overestimate the speed of physiological labor. The objective of this review is to establish an overview of synonyms and definitions used in the literature for prolonged labor, separated into first and second stages, and establish types of definitions used. A systematic search was conducted in PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, Emcare, and Academic Search Premier. All articles in English that (1) attempted to define prolonged labor, (2) included a definition of prolonged labor, or (3) included any synonym for prolonged labor, were included. Data on study design, year of publication, country or region of origin, synonyms used, definition of prolonged first and/or second stage, and origin of provided definition (if not primarily established by the study) were collected into a database. In total, 3402 abstracts and 536 full-text papers were screened, and 232 papers were included. Our search established 53 synonyms for prolonged labor. Forty-three studies defined prolonged labor and 189 studies adopted a definition of prolonged labor. Definitions for prolonged first stage of labor were categorized into: time-based (n=14), progress-based (n=12), clinician-based (n=5), or outcome-based (n=4). For the 33 studies defining prolonged second stage, the majority of definitions (n=25) were time-based, either based on total duration or duration of no descent of the presenting part. Despite efforts to arrive at uniform labor curves, there is still little uniformity in definitions of prolonged labor. Consensus on which definition to use is called for, in order to safely and respectfully allow physiological labor progress, ensure timely management, and assess and compare incidence of prolonged labor between settings.