Return to Preinjury Levels of Participation After Superior Labral Repair in Overhead Athletes: A Systematic Review

• Published in: Journal of athletic training 2015-07, Vol.50 (7), p.767-777
• Main Authors: Sciascia, Aaron, Myers, Natalie, Kibler, W Ben, Uhl, Timothy L
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Arthroscopy; Arthroscopy - methods; Arthroscopy - rehabilitation; Athletes - statistics & numerical data; Athletic Injuries - rehabilitation; Athletic Injuries - surgery; Cartilage, Articular - injuries; Cartilage, Articular - surgery; Evidence; Failure; Humans; Information Seeking; Injuries; Outcomes of Education; Patients; Prognosis; Recovery of Function - physiology; Search Strategies; Shoulder; Sports injuries; Sports medicine; Surgery; Surgical outcomes; Systematic Review
• ISSN: 1062-6050; 1938-162X
• DOI: 10.4085/1062-6050-50.3.06

Athletes often preoperatively weigh the risks and benefits of electing to undergo an orthopaedic procedure to repair damaged tissue. A common concern for athletes is being able to return to their maximum levels of competition after shoulder surgery, whereas clinicians struggle with the ability to provide a consistent prognosis of successful return to participation after surgery. The variation in study details and rates of return in the existing literature have not supplied clinicians with enough evidence to give overhead athletes adequate information regarding successful return to participation when deciding to undergo shoulder surgery. To investigate the odds of overhead athletes returning to preinjury levels of participation after arthroscopic superior labral repair. The CINAHL, MEDLINE, and SPORTDiscus databases from 1972 to 2013. The criteria for article selection were (1) The study was written in English. (2) The study reported surgical repair of an isolated superior labral injury or a superior labral injury with soft tissue debridement. (3) The study involved overhead athletes equal to or less than 40 years of age. (4) The study assessed return to the preinjury level of participation. We critically reviewed articles for quality and bias and calculated and compared odds ratios for return to full participation for dichotomous populations or surgical procedures. Of 215 identified articles, 11 were retained: 5 articles about isolated superior labral repair and 6 articles about labral repair with soft tissue debridement. The quality range was 11 to 17 (42% to 70%) of a possible 24 points. Odds ratios could be generated for 8 of 11 studies. Nonbaseball, nonoverhead, and nonthrowing athletes had a 2.3 to 5.8 times greater chance of full return to participation than overhead/throwing athletes after isolated superior labral repair. Similarly, nonoverhead athletes had 1.5 to 3.5 times greater odds for full return than overhead athletes after labral repair with soft tissue debridement. In 1 study, researchers compared surgical procedures and found that overhead athletes who underwent isolated superior labral repair were 28 times more likely to return to full participation than those who underwent concurrent labral repair and soft tissue debridement (P < .05). The rate of return to participation after shoulder surgery within the literature is inconsistent. Odds of returning to preinjury levels of participation after arthroscopic superior labral repair with or wi