Compositionality and the angular gyrus: A multi-voxel similarity analysis of the semantic composition of nouns and verbs

• Published in: Neuropsychologia 2015-11, Vol.78, p.130-141
• Main Authors: Boylan, Christine, Trueswell, John C., Thompson-Schill, Sharon L.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adolescent; Adult; Angular gyrus; Anterior temporal lobe; Brain Mapping; Comprehension - physiology; Conceptual combination; Humans; Language Tests; Magnetic Resonance Imaging; Models, Neurological; Models, Psychological; Neuropsychological Tests; Parietal Lobe - physiology; Pattern Recognition, Visual - physiology; Pattern similarity analysis; Photic Stimulation; Reading; Semantic composition; Semantics; Young Adult
• ISSN: 0028-3932; 1873-3514
• DOI: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2015.10.007

The cognitive and neural systems that enable conceptual processing must support the ability to combine (and recombine) concepts to form an infinite number of ideas. Two candidate neural systems for conceptual combination—the left anterior temporal lobe (ATL) and the left angular gyrus (AG)—have been characterized as “semantic hubs” due to both functional and anatomical properties; however, these two regions likely support different aspects of composition. Here we consider two hypotheses for the role of AG in conceptual combination, both of which differ from a putative role for the ATL in “feature-based” combinatorics (i.e., meaning derived by combining concepts' features). Firstly, we examine whether AG is more sensitive to function-argument relations of the sort that arise when a predicate is combined with its arguments. Secondly, we examine the non-mutually exclusive possibility that AG represents information carried on a verb in particular, whether this be information about event composition or about thematic relations denoted uniquely by verbs. We identified voxels that respond differentially to two-word versus one-word stimuli, and we measured the similarity of the patterns in these voxels evoked by (1) pairs of two-word phrases that shared a noun that was an argument, thus sharing function-argument composition (e.g. eats meat and with meat), in comparison with two-word phrases that shared only a noun, not an argument (e.g., eats meat and tasty meat); and (2) stimulus pairs that shared only an event (operationalized here as sharing a verb; e.g. eats meat and eats quickly), in comparison to both of the above. We found that activity patterns in left AG tracked information relating to the presence of an event-denoting verb in a pair of two-word phrases. We also found that the neural similarity in AG voxel patterns between two phrases sharing a verb correlated with subjects’ ratings of how similar the meanings of those two verb phrases were. These findings indicate that AG represents information specific to verbs, perhaps event structure or thematic relations mediated by verbs, as opposed to argument structure in general. •We analyze multi-voxel pattern similarity to investigate semantic composition.•We compare two ways in which angular gyrus (AG) might contain thematic information.•We find that AG is specifically sensitive to semantic information carried on a verb.•Study suggests “feature/function” dichotomy between anterior temporal lobe and AG.