Patient Representation in Medical Literature: Are We Appropriately Depicting Diversity?

• Published in: Plastic and reconstructive surgery. Global open 2019-12, Vol.7 (12), p.e2563-e2563
• Main Authors: Massie, Jonathan P., Cho, Daniel Y., Kneib, Cameron J., Burns, Jacob R., Crowe, Christopher S., Lane, Megan, Shakir, Afaaf, Sobol, Danielle L., Sabin, Janice, Sousa, Janelle D., Rodriguez, Eduardo D., Satterwhite, Thomas, Morrison, Shane D.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Special Topic
• ISSN: 2169-7574; 2169-7574
• DOI: 10.1097/GOX.0000000000002563

BACKGROUND:Racial disparities exist in the accessibility, delivery, and quality of healthcare. Clinical images are central to plastic surgery, but choice of images in the literature is susceptible to implicit biases. The objective of this study was to determine if published images reflect the racial demographic of patients. METHODS:A search for color photographs and rendered graphics depicting human skin was completed in 6 plastic surgery journals and the New England Journal of Medicine Images in Clinical Medicine for each decade between 1992 and 2017. For each article, images were categorized as white or nonwhite based on Fitzpatrick Scale (1–3 versus 4–6). Additionally, the authors’ geographic region was documented. Proportional data and average number of nonwhite images per article were compared. Regression analyses were performed to assess the correlation of time and geographic region on nonwhite images. RESULTS:In total, 24,209 color photographs and 1,671 color graphics were analyzed. In plastic surgery journals, 22% of photographs were nonwhite and the average number of photographs per article with white skin was 5.4 compared with 1.6 with nonwhite skin (P < 0.0001). There was a significant increase in nonwhite photographs over time (r = 0.086, P < 0.001) and association of nonwhite photographs with international authors (r = 0.12, P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS:Roughly 60%–70% of the world population and 30% of US cosmetic patients are nonwhite. Images in plastic surgery literature reflect neither racial demographics by global region nor the patient population seeking surgery. To advance equitable care, images should better represent the racial composition of the populations served.