Was Cinderella just a fairy tale? Survival differences between stepchildren and their half-siblings

• Published in: Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B. Biological sciences 2021-06, Vol.376 (1827), p.1-8, Article rstb.2020.0032
• Main Authors: Schacht, Ryan, Meeks, Huong, Fraser, Alison, Smith, Ken R.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adolescent; Child; Child, Preschool; Family Characteristics; Fathers - statistics & numerical data; Female; Humans; Infant; Male; Marriage - statistics & numerical data; Mortality; Mothers - statistics & numerical data; Part VI: Supporting Child Survival and Development; Siblings - psychology; Social Support; Utah
• ISSN: 0962-8436; 1471-2970
• DOI: 10.1098/rstb.2020.0032

The death of a parent, particularly the mother, is linked to a suite of negative outcomes across the life-course. Compounding concerns for child outcomes are expectations of poor treatment by step-parents after parental remarriage. Indeed, folk tales of step-parental abuse abound cross-culturally and are embedded into stories taught to children. To understand why child outcomes might be sensitive to levels of relatedness within the household, evolutionary-oriented research targets patterning in parental expenditure in ways predicted to maximize inclusive fitness. In particular, parents are expected to prioritize investments in their biological children. However, stepfamilies are only formed after children experience multiple unfortunate events (e.g. parental loss, poverty), blurring causal interpretations between step-parental presence and stepchild outcomes. Moreover, stepchildren have been shown to be integral to household functioning, caring for their half-siblings and stabilizing relationships. These results challenge narrow views of adaptive behaviour; specifically, that step-parents, unlike biological parents, do no stand to reap fitness benefits from the care that they provide to their stepchildren. To evaluate these critiques, we analyse the survival outcomes of stepchildren. We include over 400 000 individuals from across a natural fertility period (1847–1940) in the United States state of Utah and examine the consequences of parental loss and step-parental introduction. Our analyses yield three key results: (i) exposure to maternal loss in childhood is associated with elevated mortality risk, (ii) parental remarriage does not increase the risk of mortality among stepchildren compared to non-stepchildren who too had lost a parent, and (iii) stepchildren enjoy higher survival than their half-siblings within the same family. Ultimately, this work contributes to the increasingly recognized importance of cooperative relationships among non-kin for childcare and household functioning. This article is part of the theme issue 'Multidisciplinary perspectives on social support and maternal–child health'.