Task-dependent contrast gain in anomalous trichromats

• Published in: Vision research (Oxford) 2021-07, Vol.184, p.14-22
• Main Authors: Vanston, John E., Tregillus, Katherine E.M., Webster, Michael A., Crognale, Michael A.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adaptation; Anomalous trichromacy; Color Perception; Color vision; Color Vision Defects; Contrast; Contrast Sensitivity; Humans; Psychophysics; Retinal Cone Photoreceptor Cells; Vision
• ISSN: 0042-6989; 1878-5646
• DOI: 10.1016/j.visres.2021.02.003

•Anomalous trichromatic suprathreshold matching closer to controls than at threshold.•Anomalous trichromatic contrast reaction times instead consistent with thresholds.•Compensation in anomalous trichromacy likely dependent on task chosen to test it. Anomalous trichromacy is a form of color vision deficiency characterized by the presence of three cone types, but with shifted spectral sensitivities for L or M cones, causing a red-green color deficiency. However, long-term adaptation to this impoverished opponent input may allow for a more normal color experience at the suprathreshold level (“compensation”). Recent experimental evidence points to the presence of compensation in some tasks. The current study used threshold detection, suprathreshold contrast matching, and a reaction-time task to compare contrast coding in normal and anomalous observers along the cardinal cone-opponent axes. Compared to color normals, anomals required more L-M contrast, but not S contrast, to detect stimuli and to match an achromatic reference stimulus. Reaction times were measured for several contrast levels along the two cone-opponent axes. Anomals had higher overall reaction times, but their reaction-time versus contrast functions could be matched to those of controls simply by scaling contrast by the detection thresholds. Anomalous participants were impaired relative to controls for L-M stimuli in all three tasks. However, the contrast losses were three times greater for thresholds and reaction times than for suprathreshold matches. These data provide evidence for compensation in anomalous trichromats, but highlight the role that the experimental task plays in revealing it.