Understanding and Overcoming the Challenges Related to Cardiovascular Trials Involving Patients with Kidney Disease

• Published in: Clinical journal of the American Society of Nephrology 2021-09, Vol.16 (9), p.1435-1444
• Main Authors: Ishida, Julie H, Chauhan, Cynthia, Gillespie, Barbara, Gruchalla, Ken, McCullough, Peter A, Quella, Susan, Romero, Alain, Rossignol, Patrick, Wheeler, David C, Malley, Meaghan A, West, Melissa, Herzog, Charles A
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cardiology and cardiovascular system; Cardiovascular Diseases - complications; Clinical Trials as Topic - standards; Human health and pathology; Humans; Kidney Diseases - complications; Life Sciences; Patient Selection; Research Design
• ISSN: 1555-9041; 1555-905X
• DOI: 10.2215/CJN.17561120

Cardiovascular disease is a prevalent and prognostically important comorbidity among patients with kidney disease, and individuals with kidney disease make up a sizeable proportion (30%-60%) of patients with cardiovascular disease. However, several systematic reviews of cardiovascular trials have observed that patients with kidney disease, particularly those with advanced kidney disease, are often excluded from trial participation. Thus, currently available trial data for cardiovascular interventions in patients with kidney disease may be insufficient to make recommendations on the optimal approach for many therapies. The Kidney Health Initiative, a public-private partnership between the American Society of Nephrology and the US Food and Drug Administration, convened a multidisciplinary, international work group and hosted a stakeholder workshop intended to understand and develop strategies for overcoming the challenges with involving patients with kidney disease in cardiovascular clinical trials, with a particular focus on those with advanced disease. These efforts considered perspectives from stakeholders, including academia, industry, contract research organizations, regulatory agencies, patients, and care partners. This article outlines the key challenges and potential solutions discussed during the workshop centered on the following areas for improvement: building the business case, re-examining study design and implementation, and changing the clinical trial culture in nephrology. Regulatory and financial incentives could serve to mitigate financial concerns with involving patients with kidney disease in cardiovascular trials. Concerns that their inclusion could affect efficacy or safety results could be addressed through thoughtful approaches to study design and risk mitigation strategies. Finally, there is a need for closer collaboration between nephrologists and cardiologists and systemic change within the nephrology community such that participation of patients with kidney disease in clinical trials is prioritized. Ultimately, greater participation of patients with kidney disease in cardiovascular trials will help build the evidence base to guide optimal management of cardiovascular disease for this population.