Transposon dynamics and the epigenetic switch hypothesis

• Published in: Theoretical medicine and bioethics 2021-08, Vol.42 (3-4), p.137-154
• Main Authors: Linquist, Stefan, Fullerton, Brady
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Education; Environmental changes; Epigenetics; Ethics; Evolutionary biology; General Surgery; Genomes; Heredity; Heritability; History of Medicine; Hypotheses; Philosophy; Philosophy of Medicine; Theory of Medicine/Bioethics; Transposons
• ISSN: 1386-7415; 1573-1200; 1573-0980
• DOI: 10.1007/s11017-021-09548-x

The recent explosion of interest in epigenetics is often portrayed as the dawning of a scientific revolution that promises to transform biomedical science along with developmental and evolutionary biology. Much of this enthusiasm surrounds what we call the epigenetic switch hypothesis, which regards certain examples of epigenetic inheritance as an adaptive organismal response to environmental change. This interpretation overlooks an alternative explanation in terms of coevolutionary dynamics between parasitic transposons and the host genome. This raises a question about whether epigenetics researchers tend to overlook transposon dynamics more generally. To address this question, we surveyed a large sample of scientific publications on the topics of epigenetics and transposons over the past fifty years. We found that enthusiasm for epigenetics is often inversely related to interest in transposon dynamics across the four disciplines we examined. Most surprising was a declining interest in transposons within biomedical science and cellular and molecular biology over the past two decades. Also notable was a delayed and relatively muted enthusiasm for epigenetics within evolutionary biology. An analysis of scientific abstracts from the past twenty-five years further reveals systematic differences among disciplines in their uses of the term epigenetic , especially with respect to heritability commitments and functional interpretations. Taken together, these results paint a nuanced picture of the rise of epigenetics and the possible neglect of transposon dynamics, especially among biomedical scientists.