Mutation or not, what directly establishes a neoplastic state, namely cellular immortality and autonomy, still remains unknown and should be prioritized in our research

• Published in: Journal of Cancer 2022-01, Vol.13 (9), p.2810-2843
• Main Authors: Zhu, Shengming, Wang, Jiangang, Zellmer, Lucas, Xu, Ningzhi, Liu, Mei, Hu, Yun, Ma, Hong, Deng, Fei, Yang, Wenxiu, Liao, Dezhong Joshua
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cancer; Cell division; Chromosomes; Genes; Genetic disorders; Genomes; Medical research; Mutation; Pathogens; Review; Surveillance; Tumorigenesis
• ISSN: 1837-9664; 1837-9664
• DOI: 10.7150/jca.72628

Although the concept that cancer is caused by mutations has been widely accepted, there still are ample data deprecating it. For example, embryonic cells displaced in non-embryonic environments may develop to cancer, whereas cancer cells placed in embryonic environments may be reverted to phenotypic normal. Although many intracellular or extracellular aberrations are known to be able to initiate a lengthy tumorigenesis, the molecular or cellular alterations that directly establish a neoplastic state, namely cellular immortality and autonomy, still remain unknown. Hereditary traits are encoded not only by gene sequences but also by karyotype and DNA or chromosomal structures that may be altered via non-mutational mechanisms, such as post-translational modifications of nuclear proteins, to initiate tumorigenesis. However, the immortal and autonomous nature of neoplasms makes them “new” organisms, meaning that neoplasms should have mutations to distinguish themselves from their host patients in the genome. Neoplasms are malignant if they bear epigenetic or genetic alterations in mutator genes, i.e. the genes whose alterations accelerate other genes to mutate, whereas neoplasms are benign if their epigenetic or genetic aberrations occur only in non-mutator genes. Future mechanistic research should be focused on identifying the alterations that directly establish cellular immortality and autonomy. Benign tumors may have many fewer alterations and thus be much better models than cancers for such research. Future translational research should be aimed at identifying the cellular factors that control cancer cells' phenotypes and at establishing approaches of directing cancer cells towards differentiation, which should be a promising therapeutic tactic.