Child protection investigations by private consultants or municipally employed social workers: What are the differences for children?

• Published in: Journal of social work : JSW 2023-01, Vol.23 (1), p.103-121
• Main Authors: Bergman, Ann-Sofie, Arnesson, Kerstin, Berggren, Ulrika Järkestig
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: child and family welfare; child protection; Child welfare; Children; Children & youth; children's rights; Cities; Consultants; Participation; Protection; Social services; Social work; Social workers; Socialt arbete
• ISSN: 1468-0173; 1741-296X; 1741-296X
• DOI: 10.1177/14680173221109710

Summary In Sweden, a practice has developed where the social services have started to hire private consultants in child protection investigations. This article analyses and compares the handling of child protection investigations carried out by private consultants and municipally employed social workers with regard to the reasons for the reports, the investigations, the assessments, and the decisions taken about interventions. The concepts funnel and filtering and children's participation are used in the analysis. The study has a mixed-methods design, where qualitative and quantitative data and analysis are combined and integrated. Data consists of 120 case files regarding the social service's handling of investigations as well as interviews with managers of social service departments. Findings The results show several differences in the handling of child protection investigations carried out by social workers and private consultants in the municipalities studied. The private consultants worked to a greater extent with investigations that were initiated due to concerns about violence. Investigations conducted by consultants contained less information and specifically concerning children's perspective. These children also received interventions to a lesser extent than children assessed by the municipal social workers. Application The study indicates that from a child’s perspective, it matters whether a municipally employed social worker or a private consultant performs an investigation. Consultants generally work temporarily in a workplace, and it may therefore be more difficult to establish a trusting relationship with the children, which can be a barrier to children's participation and the implementation of a child’s perspective.