A practical guide for evaluating the osteoimmunomodulatory properties of biomaterials

• Published in: Acta biomaterialia 2021-08, Vol.130, p.115-137
• Main Authors: Mestres, Gemma, Carter, Sarah-Sophia D., Hailer, Nils P., Diez-Escudero, Anna
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Biomaterials; Biomedical materials; Bioreactors; Bone biomaterials; Bone growth; Bones; Cell culture; Culture media; Immune cells; Immune response; Immune system; Immunology; In vitro; Information processing; Markers; Methods; Microfluidics; Osteoimmunology; Production methods; Regeneration; Regeneration (physiology); Skeletal cells; Surgical implants
• ISSN: 1742-7061; 1878-7568; 1878-7568
• DOI: 10.1016/j.actbio.2021.05.038

Biomaterials offer a promising approach to repair bone defects. Whereas traditional studies predominantly focused on optimizing the osteogenic capacity of biomaterials, less focus has been on the immune response elicited by them. However, the immune and skeletal systems extensively interact, a concept which is referred to as ‘osteoimmunology’. This realization has fuelled the development of biomaterials with favourable osteoimmunomodulatory (OIM) properties, aiming to modulate the immune response and to support bone regeneration, thereby affecting the success of an implant. Given the plethora of in vitro assays used to evaluate the OIM properties of biomaterials, it may be challenging to select the right methods to produce conclusive results. In this review, we aim to provide a comprehensive and practical guide for researchers interested in studying the OIM properties of biomaterials in vitro. After a concise overview of the concept of osteoimmunology, emphasis is put on the methodologies that are regularly used to evaluate the OIM properties of biomaterials. First, a description of the most commonly used cell types and cell culture media is provided. Second, typical experimental set-ups and their relevant characteristics are discussed. Third, a detailed overview of the generally used methodologies and readouts, including cell type-specific markers and time points of analysis, is given. Finally, we highlight the promise of advanced approaches, namely microarrays, bioreactors and microfluidic-based systems, and the potential that these may offer to the osteoimmunology field. Osteoimmunology focuses on the connection and communication between the skeletal and immune systems. This interaction has been recognized to play an important role in the clinical success of biomaterials, which has resulted in an increasing amount of research on the osteoimmunomodulatory (OIM) properties of biomaterials. However, the amount of literature makes it challenging to extract the information needed to design experiments from beginning to end, and to compare obtained results to existing work. This article intends to serve as a guide for those aiming to learn more about the commonly used experimental approaches in the field. We cover early-stage choices, such as cell types and experimental set-ups, but also discuss specific assays, including cell markers and time points of analysis. [Display omitted]