120‐years of ecological monitoring data shows that the risk of overhunting is increased by environmental degradation for an isolated marine mammal population: The Baltic grey seal

• Published in: The Journal of animal ecology 2024-05, Vol.93 (5), p.525-539
• Main Authors: Carroll, Daire, Ahola, Markus P., Carlsson, Anja M., Sköld, Martin, Harding, Karin C.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Biological Sciences; Biologiska vetenskaper; Climate change; Demography; Ecological monitoring; Ecology; Ecosystems and species history; Ekologi; Ekosystem och arthistoria; Environmental changes; Environmental degradation; Environmental impact; Environmental stress; Fecundity; Fertility; Grey seals; Halichoerus grypus; human-wildlife conflict; Hunting; life history; Mammals; Man and the environment; marine mammal; Marine mammals; Naturmiljö och människan; Overfishing; overharvesting; Overhunting; Pollution; Population; Population decline; Population growth; population modelling; Population number; population viability analysis; Quotas; Recovery; Sustainability management; Zoologi; Zoology
• ISSN: 0021-8790; 1365-2656; 1365-2656
• DOI: 10.1111/1365-2656.14065

The Baltic Sea is home to a genetically isolated and morphologically distinct grey seal population. This population has been the subject of 120‐years of careful documentation, from detailed records of bounty statistics to annual monitoring of health and abundance. It has also been exposed to a range of well‐documented stressors, including hunting, pollution and climate change. To investigate the vulnerability of marine mammal populations to multiple stressors, data series relating to the Baltic grey seal population size, hunt and health were compiled, vital demographic rates were estimated, and a detailed population model was constructed. The Baltic grey seal population fell from approximately 90,000 to as few as 3000 individuals during the 1900s as the result of hunting and pollution. Subsequently, the population has recovered to approximately 55,000 individuals. Fertility levels for mature females have increased from 9% in the 1970s to 86% at present. The recovery of the population has led to demands for increased hunting, resulting in a sudden increase in annual quotas from a few hundred to 3550 in 2020. Simultaneously, environmental changes, such as warmer winters and reduced prey availability due to overfishing, are likely impacting fecundity and health. Future population development is projected for a range of hunting and environmental stress scenarios, illustrating how hunting, in combination with environmental degradation, can lead to population collapse. The current combined hunting quotas of all Baltic Nations caused a 10% population decline within three generations in 100% of simulations. To enable continued recovery of the population, combined annual quotas of less than 1900 are needed, although this quota should be re‐evaluated annually as monitoring of population size and seal health continues. Sustainable management of long‐lived slowly growing species requires an understanding of the drivers of population growth and the repercussions of management decisions over many decades. The case of the Baltic grey seal illustrates how long‐term ecological time series are pivotal in establishing historical baselines in population abundance and demography to inform sustainable management. Due to its isolation, the Baltic grey seal is subject to increased environmental stress relative to populations elsewhere. In this study, 120‐years of data on this unique population are compiled and its future growth is modelled. Current hunting quotas in the Baltic ar