Evolutionary Analyses of Base-Pairing Interactions in DNA and RNA Secondary Structures

• Published in: Molecular biology and evolution 2020-02, Vol.37 (2), p.576-592
• Main Authors: Golden, Michael, Murrell, Benjamin, Martin, Darren, Pybus, Oliver G, Hein, Jotun
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Medicin och hälsovetenskap; Methods
• ISSN: 0737-4038; 1537-1719; 1537-1719
• DOI: 10.1093/molbev/msz243

Abstract Pairs of nucleotides within functional nucleic acid secondary structures often display evidence of coevolution that is consistent with the maintenance of base-pairing. Here, we introduce a sequence evolution model, MESSI (Modeling the Evolution of Secondary Structure Interactions), that infers coevolution associated with base-paired sites in DNA or RNA sequence alignments. MESSI can estimate coevolution while accounting for an unknown secondary structure. MESSI can also use graphics processing unit parallelism to increase computational speed. We used MESSI to infer coevolution associated with GC, AU (AT in DNA), GU (GT in DNA) pairs in noncoding RNA alignments, and in single-stranded RNA and DNA virus alignments. Estimates of GU pair coevolution were found to be higher at base-paired sites in single-stranded RNA viruses and noncoding RNAs than estimates of GT pair coevolution in single-stranded DNA viruses. A potential biophysical explanation is that GT pairs do not stabilize DNA secondary structures to the same extent that GU pairs do in RNA. Additionally, MESSI estimates the degrees of coevolution at individual base-paired sites in an alignment. These estimates were computed for a SHAPE-MaP-determined HIV-1 NL4-3 RNA secondary structure. We found that estimates of coevolution were more strongly correlated with experimentally determined SHAPE-MaP pairing scores than three nonevolutionary measures of base-pairing covariation. To assist researchers in prioritizing substructures with potential functionality, MESSI automatically ranks substructures by degrees of coevolution at base-paired sites within them. Such a ranking was created for an HIV-1 subtype B alignment, revealing an excess of top-ranking substructures that have been previously identified as having structure-related functional importance, among several uncharacterized top-ranking substructures.