Evaluating early-warning indicators of critical transitions in natural aquatic ecosystems

• Published in: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences - PNAS 2016-12, Vol.113 (50), p.E8089-E8095
• Main Authors: Gsell, Alena Sonia, Scharfenberger, Ulrike, Özkundakci, Deniz, Walters, Annika, Hansson, Lars-Anders, Janssen, Annette B. G., Nõges, Peeter, Reid, Philip C., Schindler, Daniel E., Van Donk, Ellen, Dakos, Vasilis, Adrian, Rita
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animals; Aquatic ecosystems; Biodiversity and Ecology; Biologi; Biological Sciences; Biostatistics; Climate; Competition; Ecology; Ecosystem; Ekologi; Environmental monitoring; Environmental Sciences; Eutrophication; Food Chain; Fresh Water; Intraguild predation; Lakes; Models, Biological; Natural Sciences; Naturvetenskap; Paleoclimate science; PNAS Plus; Predatory Behavior; Resilience indicators; Social Sciences; Time Factors; Time series; Transitions; Trophic cascade
• ISSN: 0027-8424; 1091-6490
• DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1608242113

Ecosystems can show sudden and persistent changes in state despite only incremental changes in drivers. Such critical transitions are difficult to predict, because the state of the system often shows little change before the transition. Early-warning indicators (EWIs) are hypothesized to signal the loss of system resilience and have been shown to precede critical transitions in theoretical models, paleo-climate time series, and in laboratory as well as whole lake experiments. The generalizability of EWIs for detecting critical transitions in empirical time series of natural aquatic ecosystems remains largely untested, however. Here we assessed four commonly used EWIs on long-term datasets of five freshwater ecosystems that have experienced sudden, persistent transitions and for which the relevant ecological mechanisms and drivers are well understood. These case studies were categorized by three mechanisms that can generate critical transitions between alternative states: competition, trophic cascade, and intraguild predation. Although EWIs could be detected in most of the case studies, agreement among the four indicators was low. In some cases, EWIs were detected considerably ahead of the transition. Nonetheless, our results show that at present, EWIs do not provide reliable and consistent signals of impending critical transitions despite using some of the best routinely monitored freshwater ecosystems. Our analysis strongly suggests that a priori knowledge of the underlying mechanisms driving ecosystem transitions is necessary to identify relevant state variables for successfully monitoring EWIs.