Parent-provider relationship in home visiting interventions

• Published in: Children and youth services review 2016-10, Vol.69, p.106-115
• Main Authors: Saïas, Thomas, Lerner, Emilie, Greacen, Tim, Emer, Alessandra, Guédeney, Antoine, Dugravier, Romain, Tubach, Florence, Tereno, Susana, Guédeney, Nicole
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Early childhood; Home visitors; Prevention; Qualitative study; Relationship quality
• ISSN: 0190-7409; 1873-7765
• DOI: 10.1016/j.childyouth.2016.08.004

Home visiting, while a very popular method of early childhood intervention, is not effective for all eligible at-risk families. The relationship between the home visitor and the family is central to the success of this type of intervention. This study aims to investigate, through 1024 home visit case notes from a French home visiting program, the ways in which the home visitor-family relationship develops, and identify the obstacles to and facilitators of a good quality relationship from the provider's point of vue. Results from a qualitative analysis suggest that the factors associated to the quality of relationship are present within the very first moments of the intervention. Poor relationship quality was found to be significantly associated with the family's mistrust towards the home visitor and with poor social conditions that make the supporting relationship difficult to develop. Good relationship quality was found to be facilitated by the parents' high involvement in the intervention and associated with a feeling of isolation and an ability to form social bonds. The necessitation for home visitor training is discussed, together with a reflection on the risk of home visiting programs to increase social inequalities, when they are not flexible enough to meet families' needs. •Home visiting can be thwarted by a poor home visitors-families relationship.•Families' engagement depends on the quality of the relationship.•Quality of relationship is built in the first home visits.•Parents' needs are priority, whether they meet the programs objectives or not.•Home visiting focusing on the compliant families may increase social inequalities.