Validity limits of the maximum entropy method

• Published in: Chinese journal of physics (Taipei) 2021-06, Vol.71, p.95-111
• Main Authors: Allahverdyan, A.E., Khalafyan, E.A., Martirosyan, N.H.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bayesian decision theory; Maximum entropy method; Maximum likelihood method
• ISSN: 0577-9073
• DOI: 10.1016/j.cjph.2021.02.009

•The maximum entropy method is checked via the Bayesian decision theory.•We find types of prior information that make maximum entropy estimators meaningful.•The method can compete with the maximum likelihood method. Maximum entropy (MAXENT) is a widespread method for recovering unknown probabilities of a random variable Z. The method uses first few (empiric) moments of Z and leads to non-parametric estimators. Here we study MAXENT in a Bayesian set-up assuming that there exists a well-defined Dirichlet density for unknown probabilities. This allows to employ the average Kullback-Leibler (KL) distance in evaluating various MAXENT constraints, and comparing MAXENT with parametric estimators: the regularized maximum likelihood (ML) and the Bayesian estimator. KL distance is singled out among other distances from demanding a weak consistency of MAXENT with respect to a shrinkage. We show that MAXENT applies to sparse data, provided that there are certain types of prior information, e.g. the probabilities of Z are most probably deterministic, or there exist prior conditional rank correlations between Z and its probabilities. In the latter case MAXENT can outperform the optimally regularized ML and produce results that are close to the globally optimal Bayes estimator. Predictions of MAXENT are meaningless (i.e. worse than a random guess) if the needed prior information is absent.