Response of Vertisols, Andosols, and Alisols to paddy management

• Published in: Geoderma 2016-01, Vol.261, p.23-35
• Main Authors: Winkler, P., Kaiser, K., Kölbl, A., Kühn, T., Schad, P., Urbanski, L., Fiedler, S., Lehndorff, E., Kalbitz, K., Utami, S.R., Cao, Z., Zhang, G., Jahn, R., Kögel-Knabner, I.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Fe oxides; Ferrolysis; Paddy soils; Soil mineralogy; Soil organic matter
• ISSN: 0016-7061; 1872-6259
• DOI: 10.1016/j.geoderma.2015.06.017

Interchanging submergence and drainage in paddy soils induce alternating redox conditions. It is known that this causes changes in organic carbon stocks, in amounts and crystallinity of Fe oxides as well as transformation of clay minerals and subsequent changes in cation exchange capacity (CEC). However, the influence of the initial soil type on the extent of these changes is not yet well understood. Therefore, we studied paddy soils that derived from three different soil types (Vertisols, Andosols, Alisols) on volcanic parent material in Java (Indonesia). To account for the variability in parent materials, we additionally sampled sandstone-derived Alisols in China. Adjacent non-paddy soils were sampled as references. Samples were analyzed for texture, bulk density, clay mineral composition, total element content, pH, CEC, phosphorus retention, organic carbon (OC), and acid oxalate- (Feox) and dithionite–citrate–bicarbonate-extractable Fe (FeDCB). Only the Alisol-derived paddy soil in China showed textural changes, compared to the non-paddy soil. Evidence for paddy management induced ferrolysis was not found. The smaller topsoil clay content in the paddy soil is most probable caused by clay migration. Only minor differences in clay minerals were found; topsoils of Andosol-derived paddy soils, however, tend to be less desilicated, indicating phytolith accumulation. Except for Vertisols, paddy management caused significant depletion in Fe oxides in the topsoils (puddled layer and plow pan) due to redox processes. The extent to which the reduced Fe was leached or re-oxidized as short range-ordered Fe oxides depended on the soil texture. Andosols and sandy Alisols facilitated leaching, clayey Alisols re-oxidation. In either case, the stocks of crystalline Fe oxides diminished, causing increased proportions of short range-ordered Fe oxides. Retention of phosphorus was directly related to changes in the absolute amounts of short range-ordered Fe oxides. An accumulation of Fe oxides in paddy subsoils was not found. Lateral transport with drainage water might be a reason. In highly permeable soils with large vertical water fluxes (e.g., Andosols under paddy management), colloidal transport might also play a role. Despite losses in potential OC storage capacity (i.e., Fe oxides, clay minerals, allophane), paddy soils derived from Andosols and sandy Alisols in China had larger OC concentrations in the puddled topsoil, whereby the other soils showed no increase in OC