Taxes, informality and income shifting: Evidence from a recent Pakistani tax reform

• Published in: Journal of public economics 2018-01, Vol.157, p.41-77
• Main Author: Waseem, Mazhar
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Efficiency; Income Tax; Informality; Tax evasion
• ISSN: 0047-2727; 1879-2316
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jpubeco.2017.11.003

This paper examines firm behavior to taxation in a low enforcement and large informality setting. Using quasi-experimental variation created by a tax reform, which increased taxation of partnerships substantially relative to firms of other legal form, and the population of income tax returns filed in Pakistan in 2006–11, I document that treated firms report significantly lower earnings, migrate into informality, and switch business form in response to the increase in tax rate. The revenue loss caused by these behavioral responses is so large that by the third year after the reform the government was collecting less revenue than it would have without the tax increase. This implies that the new tax rate was on the wrong side of the Laffer curve and would not have been optimal under any social preferences. The richness of the data and tax variation permits me to decompose the observed responses into real and evasion margins and to identify fiscal externalities created by the reform on other tax bases. The welfare cost of the reform increases by around 40% once these externalities are taken into account. •Examine firm behavior to taxation in low tax capacity setting•Find that firms when facing higher taxation increase tax evasion, exit into informality, and shift legal form•Behavioral responses so large, the tax increase caused a decrease in total revenue.•The new tax rate was above the Laffer bound.•Also estimate fiscal externality on other tax bases.