Opportunity cost of water allocation to afforestation rather than conservation of natural vegetation in China

• Published in: Land use policy 2016-01, Vol.50, p.67-73
• Main Authors: Zhang, Junze, Zhao, Tingyang, Jiang, Chenchao, Cao, Shixiong
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Climate change; Ecological restoration; Ecosystem services; Environmental policy; Water consumption
• ISSN: 0264-8377; 1873-5754
• DOI: 10.1016/j.landusepol.2015.09.008

•We modeled the water costs of afforestation in China based on statistical data.•Afforestation's opportunity cost was 1100 RMBha−1 (18.9% of its service value).•Providing ecosystem services for humans inevitably creates opportunity costs.•Ecosystem service costs comprise complex, large-scale natural and social impacts. Estimation of ecosystem service values is a hot area of research in ecological conservation and economics. However, the costs of these outputs are largely unknown. In this paper, we estimated the opportunity cost of water allocated to afforestation projects through mathematical modeling based on statistical data for all of China to provide support for restoration planning based on a fuller consideration of the true costs. To guide future ecological conservation and environmental policy development, we illustrate a neglected concept (ecosystem service costs) and use this concept to compare the ecological services provided by ecological restoration based on afforestation with those of restoration based on the conservation of natural vegetation using data obtained since 1949 in China. The results showed that afforestation and natural vegetation create annual costs related to use of the available water resources equal to 4800 and 3700 RMBha−1, respectively, representing a water opportunity cost of 1100 RMBha−1 for afforestation. This illustrates the rule that “there is no free lunch” for any service, including ecosystem services. Therefore, to support the development of more effective and sustainable environmental restoration policy, it will be necessary to evaluate the associated opportunity costs.