Trophic fractionation (Δ 15N) in Collembola depends on nutritional status: A laboratory experiment and mini-review

• Published in: Pedobiologia 2011-03, Vol.54 (2), p.101-109
• Main Authors: Semenina, Eugenia E., Tiunov, Alexei V.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: C:N ratio; Detrital food webs; Fungi; Fungivores; Nitrogen; Soil communities; Stable isotopes; Starvation; Trophic shift
• ISSN: 0031-4056; 1873-1511
• DOI: 10.1016/j.pedobi.2010.10.004

Isotopic studies in temperate forest soils suggested that collembolans occupy a broad range of trophic niches. This notion is mainly based on the wide (up to 8–9‰) range of δ 15N signatures of different species. The interpretation of these data depends strongly on the correct estimation of nitrogen isotope fractionation per trophic level. It is usually assumed that a consumer is on average enriched in 15N by about 3.4‰ relative to its diet. However, trophic fractionation is not uniform across different animal taxa and different tissues, and varies with a range of factors, including quality of the diet and the nutritional status of animals. We performed a laboratory experiment aiming to compare the trophic fractionation of nitrogen isotopes (Δ 15N) in different Collembola species fed with three fungi of different palatability. Collembolans were fed with a single-species fungal diet for 75 days. There was a positive correlation between the whole body C:N ratio and reproduction rates of collembolans. We therefore used the C:N ratio as a proxy of nutritional status. In all species of collembolans, the trophic fractionation decreased with increased whole body C:N ratio, and this factor explained most of the within-species variation in Δ 15N. The analysis of published data on the trophic fractionation of collembolans in laboratory experiments confirmed this conclusion. However, the mean trophic fractionation in most collembolan species studied in the laboratory was fairly similar. In contrast, field studies have documented a consistent difference in δ 15N among different families of collembolans. In particular, in nearly all published cases Onychiuridae had δ 15N higher than Isotomidae or Entomobryidae. A sharp contrast between laboratory-based estimates of the trophic fractionation (generally uniform in different species and families) and field data (which show a consistent difference in δ 15N among different species and even families of collembolans) confirms that δ 15N values of field-collected animals bear important information on the trophic position occupied by a particular species, and are not heavily affected by the species-specific differences in trophic fractionation. As the Δ 15N in collembolans depends on their nutritional status, we suggest that the C:N values should be reported along with isotopic data to allow cross-study comparisons.