Exchange rate exposure and foreign exchange derivatives: do ineffective hedgers modify future derivatives use?

• Published in: Research in international business and finance 2004-06, Vol.18 (2), p.205-216
• Main Authors: Anderson, Brian P., Makar, Stephen D., Huffman, Stephen H.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Exchange rate exposure; Foreign exchange derivatives; Ineffective hedgers
• ISSN: 0275-5319; 1878-3384
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ribaf.2004.04.001

Recent studies examining the relationship between stock returns and exchange rate changes have provided evidence that the exchange rate exposure of non-financial companies is reduced by the use of foreign exchange derivatives. Building on such research, this study investigates whether past ineffective derivative hedging contributes to explaining future derivatives use. To the extent that companies monitor the effectiveness of their currency risk management practices, past ineffective hedgers can be expected to modify their future use of foreign exchange derivatives accordingly. In our study of 94 non-financial US multinationals, we provide evidence that the change in derivatives use from 1996–1998 to 1998–2000 can be explained in part by the ineffective hedging of currency risk in 1996–1998, controlling for variables associated with theories of optimal hedging. Additional analyses confirm that such primary results are robust to firm size, the level of foreign operations, and the use of derivatives to partially hedge currency risk. Our results imply that as exchange markets and risk management practices change, the use of derivatives to manage exchange rate risk also changes. Our contribution to this field of study is that we find evidence that past ineffective hedgers tend to increase their future use of FXDs.