Contribution of biofilm layer to virus removal in gravity-driven membrane systems with passive fouling control

• Published in: Separation and purification technology 2020-11, Vol.251, p.117336, Article 117336
• Main Authors: Tobias, Amanda, Bérubé, Pierre R.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Challenge test; Gravity-driven membrane (GDM) filtration; MS2 bacteriophage; Passive gravity-driven membrane (PGM) filtration; Pressure decay test
• ISSN: 1383-5866
• DOI: 10.1016/j.seppur.2020.117336

•PGM systems effectively removed viruses.•Effective virus removal attributed to biofilm layer.•LRVs for viruses of 4.0+ could be consistently achieved.•Standard PDTs did not reflect improved virus removal caused by biofilm layer.•Alternative PDT protocol suggested for PGM systems. Passive gravity-driven membrane (PGM) filtration is a type of gravity-driven membrane (GDM) filtration operated with passive physical fouling control measures that add limited to no complexity to the system (e.g. permeate flux interruptions, gravity-driven air scouring, system draining), allowing a greater permeate flux to be sustained. A key aspect of PGM/GDM systems is the development of a structurally loose and permeable biofilm layer on the membrane that enables a sustainable flux to be achieved and has also been associated with improved removal of humic acids, polysaccharides, proteins, assimilable organic carbon and microcystins. The present study investigated if the biofilm layer of PGM systems also contributes to virus removal, for both intact and breached PGM systems. Breach sizes considered ranged from 20 to 180 µm. Challenge tests (CTs) identified an increase of 2.0+ in the log removal value (LRV) for viruses in both intact and breached PGM systems when a biofilm layer was present, suggesting that the biofilm layer is capable of bridging the gap over integrity breaches, acting as a secondary barrier to contaminants that would otherwise bypass treatment by flowing through the breach. Pressure decay tests (PDTs), however, did not identify the same increase in LRVs as that of CTs, suggesting that the standard PDT approach cannot consider the contribution of the biofilm layer to the removal of small material such as viruses. An alternative integrity testing protocol for PGM systems was developed using a modified PDT approach that takes into account the additional removal provided by the biofilm layer. This alternative protocol is also simpler and requires less frequent testing, contributing to the simplification of overall operation of PGM systems in small/remote communities and decentralized applications.