Estimating maximum limits to mutagenic potency from cytotoxic potency

• Published in: Nature (London) 1979-05, Vol.279 (5709), p.154-156
• Main Authors: CARVER, J. H, HATCH, F. T, BRANSCOMB, E. W
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Alkylating Agents - toxicity; Animals; Cell Survival - drug effects; Cell Survival - radiation effects; Cytotoxins; Dose-Response Relationship, Drug; Dose-Response Relationship, Radiation; Humanities and Social Sciences; Humans; letter; multidisciplinary; Mutagens; Polycyclic Compounds - toxicity; Science
• ISSN: 0028-0836; 1476-4687
• DOI: 10.1038/279154a0

RAPID and reliable screening methods are required for identifying environmental mutagens and estimating their mutagenic potency in preparation for use of more elaborate tests to assess the genetic risk to man. Many compounds are effectively screened by in vitro mutagenesis assays using either bacterial or mammalian cells. Although tests with mammalian cells are not as rapid and inexpensive as microbial assays, they are needed to confirm and extend the bacterial results, and probably provide a better assessment of potential risk to humans than do microbial tests. However, the screening of all potential mutagens with mammalian cell mutagenicity assays, although desirable, does not seem feasible unless, as we propose, test compounds are first pre-screened on the basis of their cytotoxic potency. On theoretical grounds, one expects a certain minimum cytotoxic potency to correlate with mutagenic potency, particularly when the latter is measured using forward mutations that result in inactive gene products. Specifically, cells cannot divide unless a substantial fraction of their genome is functionally intact; mutagenic agents should thus be obligatory cytotoxic agents, with a given mutagenicity conferring a certain irreducible cytotoxicity. We show here that the cytotoxic potency of 22 chemical mutagens is highly correlated with their mutagenic potency as assayed in five rodent and human in vitro cell systems. This relationship implies that the maximum potential mutagenic potency of such compounds may be reliably estimated from rapid and straightforward measurements of their cytotoxic potency, the latter defined as the failure of cultured cells to undergo continued cell division. The estimate is necessarily a maximum one, as an agent may exert cytotoxic effects by pathways independent of its mutagenic action.