From Speech Illusions to Onset of Psychotic Disorder: Applying Network Analysis to an Experimental Measure of Aberrant Experiences

• Published in: Schizophrenia bulletin open 2020-01, Vol.1 (1)
• Main Authors: Boyette, Lindy-Lou, Isvoranu, Adela-Maria, Schirmbeck, Frederike, Velthorst, Eva, Simons, Claudia J P, Barrantes-Vidal, Neus, Bressan, Rodrigo, Kempton, Matthew J, Krebs, Marie-Odile, McGuire, Philip, Nelson, Barnaby, Nordentoft, Merete, Riecher-Rössler, Anita, Ruhrmann, Stephan, Rutten, Bart P, Sachs, Gabriele, Valmaggia, Lucia R, van der Gaag, Mark, Borsboom, Denny, de Haan, Lieuwe, van Os, Jim
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• ISSN: 2632-7899; 2632-7899
• DOI: 10.1093/schizbullopen/sgaa025

Abstract Aberrant perceptional experiences are a potential early marker of psychosis development. Earlier studies have found experimentally assessed speech illusions to be associated with positive symptoms in patients with psychotic disorders, but findings for attenuated symptoms in individuals without psychotic disorders have been inconsistent. Also, the role of affect is unclear. The aim of this study was to use the network approach to investigate how speech illusions relate to individual symptoms and onset of a psychotic disorder. We estimated a network model based on data from 289 Clinical High-Risk (CHR) subjects, participating in the EU-GEI project. The network structure depicts statistical associations between (affective and all) speech illusions, cross-sectional individual attenuated positive and affective symptoms, and transition to psychotic disorder after conditioning on all other variables in the network. Speech illusions were assessed with the White Noise Task, symptoms with the BPRS and transition during 24-month follow-up with the CAARMS. Affective, not all, speech illusions were found to be directly, albeit weakly, associated with hallucinatory experiences. Hallucinatory experiences, in turn, were associated with delusional ideation. Bizarre behavior was the only symptom in the network steadily predictive of transition. Affective symptoms were highly interrelated, with depression showing the highest overall strength of connections to and predictability by other symptoms. Both speech illusions and transition showed low overall predictability by symptoms. Our findings suggest that experimentally assessed speech illusions are not a mere consequence of psychotic symptoms or disorder, but that their single assessment is likely not useful for assessing transition risk.