Near Ground Pathloss Propagation Model Using Adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Inference System for Wireless Sensor Network Communication in Forest, Jungle and Open Dirt Road Environments

• Published in: Sensors (Basel, Switzerland) Switzerland), 2022-04, Vol.22 (9), p.3267
• Main Authors: Hakim, Galang P N, Habaebi, Mohamed Hadi, Toha, Siti Fauziah, Islam, Mohamed Rafiqul, Yusoff, Siti Hajar Binti, Adesta, Erry Yulian Triblas, Anzum, Rabeya
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accuracy; Adaptive systems; Analysis; Antennas; Antennas (Electronics); Communication; Communications equipment; Data transmission; Dirt; Electric waves; Electromagnetic radiation; Electromagnetic waves; Electromagnetism; Environmental effects; Forests; fuzzy ANFIS; Fuzzy Logic; Leaves; LoRa; near ground; Neural networks; pathloss propagation model; Propagation; Receivers & amplifiers; Remote sensors; RSSI; Sensors; Statistical analysis; Transmitters; Unpaved roads; Wireless communications; Wireless networks; wireless sensor network; Wireless sensor networks
• ISSN: 1424-8220; 1424-8220
• DOI: 10.3390/s22093267

In Wireless Sensor Networks which are deployed in remote and isolated tropical areas; such as forest; jungle; and open dirt road environments; wireless communications usually suffer heavily because of the environmental effects on vegetation; terrain; low antenna height; and distance. Therefore; to solve this problem; the Wireless Sensor Network communication links must be designed for their best performance using the suitable electromagnetic wave behavior model in a given environment. This study introduces and analyzes the behavior of the LoRa pathloss propagation model for signals that propagate at near ground or that have low transmitter and receiver antenna heights from the ground (less than 30 cm antenna height). Using RMSE and MAE statistical analysis tools; we validate the developed model results. The developed Fuzzy ANFIS model achieves the lowest RMSE score of 0.88 at 433 MHz and the lowest MAE score of 1.61 at 433 MHz for both open dirt road environments. The Optimized FITU-R Near Ground model achieved the lowest RMSE score of 4.08 at 868 MHz for the forest environment and lowest MAE score of 14.84 at 868 MHz for the open dirt road environment. The Okumura-Hata model achieved the lowest RMSE score of 6.32 at 868 MHz and the lowest MAE score of 26.12 at 868 MHz for both forest environments. Finally; the ITU-R Maximum Attenuation Free Space model achieved the lowest RMSE score of 9.58 at 868 MHz for the forest environment and the lowest MAE score of 38.48 at 868 MHz for the jungle environment. These values indicate that the proposed Fuzzy ANFIS pathloss model has the best performance in near ground propagation for all environments compared to other benchmark models.