Budgeting of non-commercial clinical trials: development of a budget tool by a public funding agency

• Published in: Current controlled trials in cardiovascular medicine 2019-12, Vol.20 (1), p.714-10, Article 714
• Main Authors: Nevens, Hilde, Harrison, Jillian, Vrijens, France, Verleye, Leen, Stocquart, Nelle, Marynen, Elisabeth, Hulstaert, Frank
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Budgets; Clinical trial costs; Clinical trials; Cost drivers, pragmatic; Cost Savings; Cost-Benefit Analysis; Costs; Economic aspects; Fees; Financing, Government - economics; Funding; Hospitals; Humans; Medical research; Methodology; Models, Economic; Multicenter Studies as Topic - economics; Neonatology; Non-commercial; Pharmaceutical industry; Public funding; Public Sector - economics; R&D; Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic - economics; Research & development; Research Design; Research Support as Topic - economics; Resource use; Spreadsheet software
• ISSN: 1745-6215; 1745-6215
• DOI: 10.1186/s13063-019-3900-8

Investigator-led multicentre randomised trials are essential to generate evidence on the optimal use of medical interventions. These non-commercial trials are often hampered by underfunding, which may lead to difficulties in gathering a team with the necessary expertise, a delayed trial start, slow recruitment and even early trial discontinuation. As a new public funder of pragmatic clinical trials, the KCE Trials programme was committed to correctly pay all trial activities in order to assure timely delivery of high-quality trial results. As no appropriate trial budget tool was readily publicly available that took into account the costs for the sponsor as well as the costs for participating sites, we developed a tool to make the budgeting of a clinical trial efficient, transparent and fair across applicants. All trial-related activities of the sponsor and sites were categorised, and cost drivers were identified. All elements were included in a spreadsheet tool allowing the sponsor team to calculate in detail the various activities of a clinical trial and to appreciate the budget impact of specific cost drivers, e.g. a delay in recruitment. Hourly fees by role were adapted from published data. Fixed amounts per activity were developed when appropriate. This publicly available tool has already been used for 17 trials funded since the start of the KCE Trials programme in 2016, and it continues to be used and improved. This budget tool is used together with additional risk-reducing measures such as a multistep selection process with advance payments, a recruitment feasibility check by sponsor and funder, a close monitoring of study progress and a milestone-based payment schedule with the last payment made when the manuscript is submitted. The budget tool helps the KCE Trials programme to answer relevant research questions in a timely way, within budget and with high quality, a necessary condition to achieve impact of this programme for patients, clinical practice and healthcare payers.