Plumage colouration in gulls responds to their non‐breeding climatic niche

• Published in: Global ecology and biogeography 2020-10, Vol.29 (10), p.1704-1715
• Main Authors: Dufour, Paul, Guerra Carande, Julia, Renaud, Julien, Renoult, Julien P., Lavergne, Sébastien, Crochet, Pierre‐André, Evans, Karl
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adaptation; Air temperature; Biodiversity and Ecology; biogeography; bird colouration; Birds; Bogert’s rule; Breeding seasons; Climatic conditions; Comparative analysis; Darkness; Data collection; Digital imaging; Environmental Sciences; Gloger’s rule; Interspecific; Life cycles; migration distance; Niches; photoprotection; Phylogeny; Plumage; Seasonal variations; Seasons; Species; Thermoregulation; Variation; Wing tips
• ISSN: 1466-822X; 1466-8238; 1466-822X
• DOI: 10.1111/geb.13142

Aim Global variation in animal colouration has inspired ecogeographical rules that suggest common patterns of recurrent adaptations to climate. However, little attention has been paid to the relative influence of the different climatic conditions encountered by species during their annual life cycle. We explored this question by testing whether breeding or non‐breeding climatic conditions most influence plumage colouration in gulls, a cosmopolitan group of birds with extensive variation in plumage darkness and seasonal migratory strategies. Location Global. Time period Contemporary. Major taxa studied All species and subspecies of gulls (Aves, Laridae). Methods We used literature data and digital images to assess two characteristics of plumage colouration in all 80 species and subspecies of gulls: the darkness of the mantle and the proportion of black on wingtips. For each species and subspecies, we collected data on migration distance and environmental variables across its breeding and non‐breeding range for both breeding and non‐breeding seasons. We performed a phylogenetic comparative analysis to quantify the relative influence of climatic conditions experienced during the breeding and non‐breeding season on plumage colouration. Results The climatic conditions encountered during the non‐breeding season explained interspecific variation in colouration better than the climate experienced during the breeding season. In accordance with hypotheses on the role of dark colouration in thermoregulation and feather protection, darker mantle colouration was positively correlated with insolation and negatively with air temperature. The proportion of black on wingtips was greater for long distance migrants wintering under insolated conditions than short distance migrants or residents occupying less insolated regions. Main conclusions In gulls, plumage colouration is predominantly shaped by selection experienced outside the breeding period, in accordance with the hypothesized photoprotective and thermoregulatory functions of avian plumage. This highlights the importance of taking into account seasonality and migration to understand global spatial patterns of avian colouration.