A scenario for an evolutionary selection of ageing

• Published in: eLife 2024-11, Vol.13
• Main Authors: Roget, Tristan, Macmurray, Claire, Jolivet, Pierre, Meleard, Sylvie, Rera, Michael
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Life Sciences
• ISSN: 2050-084X; 2050-084X
• DOI: 10.7554/eLife.92914.3

Signs of ageing become apparent only late in life, after organismal development is finalized. Ageing, most notably, decreases an individual’s fitness. As such, it is most commonly perceived as a non-adaptive force of evolution and considered a by-product of natural selection. Building upon the evolutionarily conserved age-related Smurf phenotype, we propose a simple mathematical life-history trait model in which an organism is characterized by two core abilities: reproduction and homeostasis. Through the simulation of this model, we observe (1) the convergence of fertility’s end with the onset of senescence, (2) the relative success of ageing populations, as compared to non-ageing populations, and (3) the enhanced evolvability (i.e. the generation of genetic variability) of ageing populations. In addition, we formally demonstrate the mathematical convergence observed in (1). We thus theorize that mechanisms that link the timing of fertility and ageing have been selected and fixed over evolutionary history, which, in turn, explains why ageing populations are more evolvable and therefore more successful. Broadly speaking, our work suggests that ageing is an adaptive force of evolution. It is a question as old as Darwin’s theory of evolution itself: how is ageing affected by natural selection? The prevailing view is that the process of biological ageing is not adaptive and therefore not directly subject to selection pressures. Take for example a gene causing a fatal disease late after an average individual had reproduced, thus being passed on to the next generation despite its detriment to the individual. This suggests that natural selection acts less strongly on such genes, which can therefore accumulate and cause aging if they do not impact an organism’s reproductive fitness earlier in life. However, many studies have shown that specific genes control an animal’s lifespan and the onset of ageing through evolutionarily conserved mechanisms. For example, in fruit flies, aging can be categorised into two distinct phases determined by the manifestation of the so-called Smurf phenotype associated with accelerated signs of ageing and an increased risk of death. A pattern where the offspring of older parents live less long than those of younger parents has also been observed across species, also known as the Lansing effect. In this case, ageing can affect the reproductive success of future generations and can therefore be subject to selection pressures. Roget et a