‘She Wanted to Listen to her General Practitioner’s Advice…’: Exploring and Explaining Antibiotic Prescribing as a Regulatory Encounter

• Published in: Medical law review 2022-05, Vol.30 (2), p.299-323
• Main Author: Carter, David J
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Antibiotics; COVID-19 (Disease); Medical care; Patients; Public health
• ISSN: 1464-3790; 1464-3790
• DOI: 10.1093/medlaw/fwac003

Abstract This article examines the pressing global problem of antimicrobial resistance (AMR), applying motivational posture theory to demonstrate how AMR and the prescribing that drives it can be considered a regulatory challenge. Following an outline of AMR and the threat of the ‘superbugs’ to which it gives rise, the article assesses the regulatory nature of the ‘prescribing encounter’ in the primary care setting. It applies both a responsive regulatory lens and motivational posture theory to analyse over 100 narrative accounts of encounters between a general practitioner and a patient. In so doing, the article examines the discursive repertoires and cultural resources available to primary care patients to explain the prescribing encounter and the dynamics within it. It concludes that patients conceive of prescribers as regulatory authorities and prescribing itself as a regulatory encounter. On this basis, the article argues that applying responsive regulatory theory and practice in response to the AMR challenge is likely to find reasonable patient acceptance, offering a new approach to this currently intractable challenge. This article then offers an analysis of what factors indicate patient drift towards defiance of regulatory aims, and what engagement and support encourage a return to cooperation.